Skip to main content

Full text of "The McGill Daily Vol. 85 No. 027: November 13, 1995"

See other formats







THE MSGILL DAILY 
CB Special Issue 


: (5 NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


Volume 85 Number 27 
Searching for M. Right since 1911 





YOUR DOWNTOWN 


, EPSON SERVICE 
ACCESS Info-Tecu ER VICE 


IN STORE STUDENT FINANCING 
Tough on the 
Road, Easy on (i | + | 
theBudget. cc 


ax mo irre > 7. 
Sigs Sree 


RRQ 
nd. L. 


EVENTS 


Monday, November 13 
+ Black Students’ Network 
Movie Night, featuring / Like It 
Like That, the first Hollywood 
film ever directed by a black 
= . woman, and Looking For 
ia i #4 À Langston, a film about back gay 
ne Bi ips American author and political 
Ft figure Langston Hughes. 19h, Lea 
26. $2 donations towards Black 
History Month at the door. All 

welcome. 

e Islam Awareness Week 
RDS DATE Will have a display in Shatner 
Re 3. NS as 107/108 all weekfrom 10h-16h. 


ActionNote | eee 
660C COLOUR 


ME OUT | 
- Fast 486DX2-66MHZ Processor 
- Large 10.3" Passive Colour Display 
with Built-In Local Bus Video 
- 8MB Ram , 340MB HDD, 3.5" FD 
- Type III PCMCIA Slot 
- Built-In Trackball 


ermonth 
979 QUANTITY. CASH PRICE ONLY 
1120 DeMaisonneuve West 


Corner Stanley 
Tel.: (514) 288 - 6000 





paki des =f 


















FOR AN 
UPGRADE 






. OPP 
PISE Paru at ae 
LS BR Se dans an 









CD-Rom, Multimedia 
Memory, Disk Drives 
Monitors, Software 


444 Rene-Levesque West. 
Corner Bleury 
P.d'Ants Tel.: (514) 288 - 6000 





PEEL 


OPTOMETRIST 


+ Eyes Examined 

¢ Eye Glasses (2 for 1) 

+ Contact Lenses (from $89) 
¢ Student Discount 


Dr. David Kwavnick, O.D. 
1535 Sherbrooke St. W. 
(corner Guy) 


933-8700 





St-Mathieu 
Dental Centre 










1/1 
Just maa’ m 
7 guitar, ear 


=x LUE, NOV. 14 sr 


NFO: 848-1010) 

12 AT CAFÉ CAMPUS (| 

ae TICKETS $ & ADMISSION. RES: 790- 1245, here 
ne aa AW 








ee 
. 


discount for 
McGill students 
on dental services | 





(LIMITED NUMBER) 
FIRST COME, FIRST SERVED 


AT THE DAILY 
BUSINESS OFFICE: 


tne 
TS 


1801 de Maisonneuve W., 
corner St-Mathieu 
Suite 730 






Tel.: 989-7245 


l'conconoa Exit St-Mathieu 





Or bring in your old 
| computer for a credit. 


ture, “Islamic Monotheism” in 
Shatner B09/B10 from 18h to 
20h. 


Tuesday, November 14 


e Post-Abortion Support 
Group meets today at 17h15 in 
Shatner 423. For info call Erin at 
398-6823 or 288-3703. 

e Islam Awareness Week 
will hold a workshop on 
Shahaada in Shatner 107 from 
14h30 to 16h. 

e TheLatin American Aware- 
ness Group meets today in 
Shatner 107/108 at 18h to dis- 
cuss the Project 
Accompagnement information 
night and fundraising. All Wel- 
come. 


FOR LESS. 


UPGRADE 


486DX2 66 = $238.50 
486DX4 75 = $378.55 
486DX4 100 = $447.60 


P75 = $685. 
P90 = S888. 
P100 = $1092. 
P)20 = $1325. 
BSED ILPYE 





1175 Crescent SI, Suite 301 
393- 8591. ‘Ge B74. 9456 


eCuban Youth Tour, thetour 
leaders are participating in a 
cross-country tour of Canadian 
universities andcolleges and will 
speak at McGill regarding “Keal- 
ity Facing Cuban Youth Today”, 
For more info call 284-0436. 


Wednesday, November 15 

e LBGTM’s Bisexual Discussion 
Group meets tonight in Shatner 
432 at 17h30. Men and Women 
welcome fora friendly, open dis- 
cussion. 

+ Islam Awareness Week 
will hold a Workshop on Knoivi- 
edgein Shatner 107 from 14h30 
to 16h and a Lecture “Our Duty 
towards The Creator and Crea- 
tion” 









Why pay big bucks for = 
today’s technology? ==": 
GHLI-DONE Upgrade your system || \ 


Service + Sales + Upgrades 


Used Equipment Available 
McGill's Affordable Alternative 


COMPUTER . 











Ant R BROCCO res PERT BRON € an rs JES EN) 0077, COREE 


ne 


ALBEIT A BAGCQOU seu PIERCE HROSUN à LAN FLEMIV,'S HMS SOND 0077 a COLNE SEAN EAN QASELLA SCH PCD 
FAMAE JANSSEN ao JOE DA PALER 3 ERIC SERA ANTHONY WAVE srw TERRY RAWLINGS 50 PHL MERELY “2 S PETER LAMONT So dag 


“SPECHT PANE * 


“EADY CONE wo BRLCE DIST "3 MOCHATL G WILSON ano BAR BROCCOU MATIN CANPEELL es En 
woe se MND vol DP TM TUNER Sommers on ce eat 


a 











—_—_——~ - 





Comment 
THE SAME UNIQUENESS 


Queer, Dyke, Fag, Bi. 
Labels. These days, we 
tend to rely on them 
more and more, to lump 
people together, to cat- 
egorise and define them. 
Granted, labels help to 
unify oppressed groups 
of people. They can pro- 
vide the means to form a 
power base and to speak 
out from it. But at the 
same time, by dividing 
people into “special in- 
terest” groups, itis much 
easier to ignore the is- 
sues that these groups 
bring up than to actually 
address them. 

Bisexual and 
Transgendered (TG) is- 
sues have been treated 
in this way. They have 
been marginalized in 
mainstream society and 
in the gay and lesbian 
community. It has been 
and still is a case of “Bi- 
sexual issues only for bi- 
sexuals” and 
“Transgendered issues 
only relate to 
transgendered people”. 
But these issues speak to 
more people than that. 

Transgendered is- 
sues arent just about 
hormones, drag, and SRS 
(see glossary). These is- 


at 





sues challenge socicty’s 


preconceived notions of 


gender roles, gender 
traits and gender, pe- 
riod. They point to how 


we all embody a mix of 


“masculine” and “femi- 
nine” traits and more im- 
portant, to how arbitrary 
these distinctions actu- 
ally are. Beyond physi- 
cal differences, the dif- 
ferences in mental, emo- 
tional and sexual differ- 
ences are slowly disap- 
pearing, as are society’s 
artificial gender roles 
that place women as 
gatherers and men as 
hunters. The roles that 
society assigns to people 
are those created by a 
male-dominated, sex- 
phobic soceity where not 
everyone has been given 
the chance to define 
themselves. All these val- 
ues and roles that soci- 
ety holds as truth need 
to be reconsidered in 
light of transsexuality. 
Bisexual politics 
also emphasise that you 
can't categorise people. 
Bisexuality challenges 
the dichotomy that you 
are either heterosexual 
or homosexual. But even 
more than that, it chal- 


THE MSGILL DAILY 
Special Issue 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


Volume 85 number 27 


Editorial Offices: 
3480 McTavish St., Montréal, Qc., 
room B-03, H3A 1X9 


Business & Advertising Office: 
3480 McTavish St., Montréal, Qc., 
room B-07, H3A 1X9 


editorial: (514) 398-6784 
business/advertising: (514) 398-6790 
fax: (514) 398-8318 


Co-ordinating Editor: M-J Milloy 
Co-ordinating News Editor: Robin Perelle 
News Editors: Anup Grewal, Jacqueline 
Reis 

Culture Editor: Kevin Siu 

Features Editor: Idella Sturino 

Science Editor: - 

Layout & Design Co-ordinator: 

Derek Fung 

Daily Francais: Anne Caporal, Atim Leon 
Photo Editors: Cameron Booth, David 
Ryther 

National Affairs Editor: - 

Office Manager: Dominique Nouvet 


Business Manager: 

Marian Schrier 

Assistant Business Manager: 
Jo-Anne Pickel 

Advertising Managers: 

Boris Shedov, Letty Matteo 
Advertising Layout & Design: 
Mark Booker 


Contributors: 


Chris Carter, Meredith Cohen 
Max Francisco, M. Engelbert Grif- 
fin, Jason Kleine, Andrea Mason, 
Jen Mooney, Sam Murphy, 
Melanie Newton, Karen Tamaki, 
Mera Thompson, Sonia Verma 


Cover by Derek Fung 


Special Issue Coordinators: Derek 
Fung and Kevin Siu 


All contents ©1995 Daily Publications Society. All rights reserved. The 
content of this newspaper is the responsibility of the McGill Daily and does not 
necessarily represent the views of McGill University or the Students’ Society of 
McGill University. Products or companies advertized in this newspaper are not 
necessarily endorsed by the Daily staff. Printed by Interhauf Developments Inc., 


Montréal, Québec. 


The Daily is a founding member of Canadian University Press, Presse étudiante 


du Québec, and Publi-Peq. 


Computers supplied by the McGill Computer Store 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 





lenges the notion of “ei- 
ther/or.” Bisexual peo- 
ple represent the full 
spectrum of human ex- 
istence: from practically 
hetero to almost homo, 
from kinky to vanilla, 
from. monogamous to 
polyamorous, Every sin- 
gle permutation exists 
within the scope of bi- 
sexuality and that is the 
beauty of it. To try to 
reduce everyone to these 
categories is to try to 
cover up and hide the 
natural and evolved va- 
riety of human existence. 
Bisexual people reflect 
the diversity within any 
given group and shows 
that these little black 
boxes to which people 
have been assigned to 
just don’t work. 

The bisexual and 
transgendered move- 
ments both suggest that 
people cannot be classi- 
fied into rigid “either/ 
or” categories and roles. 
Instead it suggests that 
continuums Of sexuality, 
of gender, of race, of age 
exist. Each person exists 
somewhere along these 
continuums, not defined 
by limits, but by arange 
of possibilities. Each per- 
son is at some point of 
human experience and it 
is this diversity that cre- 
ates the lattice of life. 

The danger in con- 
stant labelling and cat- 
egorising is that it will 
reduce the rich tapestry 
of life to a single thread. 
Instead of trying to de- 
fine each and every sin- 
gle second of human ex- 
istence, why not revel in 
the differences that 
makes each person 
unique and remember 
what makes us all hu- 
man: the capacity to love, 
empathise and destroy. 
What a boring world this 
would be if we were all 
the same. 

In the end, I hope 
that this issue will help 
celebrate the different 
ways of existing in this 
world. And though there 
are differences, remem- 
ber that we are morealike 
than we are unlike. We 
are all human. 


Derek Fung 





TABLE OF 
CONTENTS 


Page 4: What do they mean?: A glossary of 
terms used to describe gender identity 








Page 9: Lesbian Bisexual Gay Transgender 
McGill: The evolution of LBGTM 





Page 6: Where is McGill’s policy on sexual 
orientation?: Students and faculty look for 
an answer 





Page 7: Queer in Ontario: Ontario’s right 
wing darling, Mike Harris doesn’t do much 
for the queer community. 

The Triangle Programme: Toronto sets 
up separate classes lor gay and lesbian 
students 





Page 8: Biphobia in Montréal: Does the city’s 
gay and lesbian community exclude bi- 
sexuals and transgendered people? 

segregation in the LBGT community: 
Looking at the riftbetween men and women 





Page 9: Lesbian rights: Sexual orientation 
clause deleted at the UN World Conference 
on Women 





Pages 10-11: Talking about the bisexual 
movement: An Interview with San Francis- 
co’s Maggi Rubenstein, one of the first out 
bisexuals in North America 





Page 12: Thoughts on gender identity: An 
interview with McGill’s Olivia Jensen 





Page 13: Changing your sex: The sex reas- 
signment process 





Page 14: Anti-gay legislation in the US: 
Colorado’s Amendment 2 is brought to the 
Supreme Court 





Page 15: Looking for a gay gene: Does the 
nature versus nurture debate really mat- 
ter? 





Page 16: The question of equality: Two 
documentaries recently shown at the Im- 
age & Nation film festival 





Page 17: Coming out: The stories of two 
McGill students 





Page 18: The strange customs of Canada: 


Border guards continue to detain LBGT 
literature 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 





8 SEXUAL IDENTITY AND 


GENDER IDENTITY GLOSSARY 


he following isa glossary 

of some basic terms used 

in describing gender and 
sexual identity. These 
meanings, however, are 
continually changing and are 
used differently by different 
individuals in different 
contexts. The definitions 
assume the existence of only 
two sexes and genders which 
many people consider closely 
related or overlapping. In this 
way, they may presenta limited 
view of a much richer reality, 

Despite these caveats, 
many people find the terms 
listed here useful in varying 
degrees, even if only as a 
Starting point for describing 
how their view of the world 
differs from that represented 
here, 

Bearin mind that gender 
identity refers to whether one 
thinks of oneself as a man 
(masculine) or as a woman 
(feminine), gender/sex is 
whether one has a vagina ora 
penis and gender roles are 
society's arbitrarily prescribed 
rules for how people are 
supposed to behave based on 
their sex, 

Sexual identity refers to 
Whom one is sexually and 
romantically attracted, When 


one’s sex and gender identity 


are different, sexual identity 
can be based on either one. 
Alternatively, one may have 
lwo sexual identities, one as a 
man and one as a Woman, 


Androgeny: !he quality of 


simultaneously exhibiting 
‘masculine’ and ‘feminine’ 
characteristics, 

Benjamin Standards, The: | lic 
international guidelines 
developed by Dr. Harry 
Benjamin regarding 
requirements of applicants 
for hormone 
andsexual reassignment 
SUTYCTY, 

Bigendered: One who switches 
between masculine and 
feminine gender roles 
periodically. 

Biphobia: The oppression or 
mistreatment of bisexuals, 
especially by lesbians and 
gay men. 

Bisexual: One who has 
Significant sexual and 
romantic attractions to 
members of both the same 
and the other sex, or who 
identify as members of the 
bisexual community. 

Butch: |. ‘Masculine’ or macho 
dress and behaviour, 


regardless of sex or gender 


identity. 2, A sub-identity 
of lesbian or gay, based on 
‘masculine’ or macho dress 
and behaviour. 

Come out: |. To disclose one’s 
own sexual identity to 


therapy 


another, 2. To discover that 
one’s own sexual identity is 
different than previously 
assumed, 3. To deal with 
one’s own and others’ 
reactions to the discovery or 
revelation of one’s sexual 
identity. \ 

Drag: 1.Clothes, often unusual 
or dramatic, especially those 
considered appropriate to 
the other sex. 2. Can be 
applied to any recognisable 
‘look’ (¢.g. “I see you are in 
corporate drag today”). 

Dyke: Keclaimed derogatory 
slang. Refers to lesbians, or 
to lesbians andbisexual 
women, 

F2M: I'emale to male. Used to 
specify the direction of a sex 
or gender role change. 

Femme: |. ‘feminine’ or 
effeminate dress and 
behaviour, regardless of sex 
or gender identity. 2. A sub- 
identity of lesbian or gay, 
based on ‘masculine? or 
macho dress and behaviour. 

Gay: One who has significant 
sexual and romantic 
attractions primarily to 
members of the same sex, or 
who identifies as a member 
of the gay community, Can 
refer to gay males or both 
gay males and /esbians. 
Although some use the term 
gav community to refer to 
all sexual minorities, lesbians 
and bisexuals often do not 
feel included by it, 

Gender (identity): A 
psychological gender role 
(i.c. ‘masculine’ or 
‘feminine’), 

Gender (identity) community: 
People who identify as 
transvestite, transsexual, or 
transgendered, Members of 
the gender community do 
not necessarily identify as 
members of the sexual 
minority community. 

Gender dysphoria (GD): 
Unhappiness or discomfort 
experienced by one whose 
sexual organs do not match 
one’s gender identity. 

Gender neutral: Clothing, 
behaviours, thoughts, 
feelings, relationships, etc, 
Which are considered 
appropriate for members of 
both sexes, 

Gender role: Arbitrary rules 
assigned by society, that 
define what clothing, 
behaviours, thoughts, 
feelings, relationships, etc. 
are considered appropriate 
and inappropriate for 
members of each sex. What 
is considered ‘masculine,’ 
‘feminine,’ or‘neutral' varies 
according to location, class, 
occasion, and numerous 
other factors. 


Genetic male/man (GM): Onc 


who was considered male 


NovemBer 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


from birth, regardless of 
one’s present sex or gender 


identity. 
Genetic female/woman (GF/ 
GM): One who was 


considered female from 
birth, regardless of one’s 
present sex or gender 
identity. 

Hermaphrodite: One who has 
both a penis and a vagina. 
Considered derogatory. 

Heterosexual (het): One who 
has significant sexual and 
romantic attractions 
primarily to members of the 
other sex, 

Heterosexism: The 
assumption that identifying 
as heterosexual and having 
sexual and romantic 
attractions only to members 
of the other sex is good and 
acceptable, and that other 


sexual identities and 
attractions are bad and 
unacceptable. The 


assumption that anyone 
whose sexual orientation is 
not known must be straight. 
Homophobia: Originally, afear 
of sexual attraction to the 
same sex. Developed into a 
term describing all aspects 
of the oppression of lesbians, 


gays, and _— bisexuals 
(sometimes does not include 
bisexuals). 


Homosexual: l'ormalor clinical 
term for gay, usually 
meaning gay male, but can 
refer to lesbian or bisexual. 
Homosexual and 
homosexuality are terms 
often associated with the 
proposition that same 
gender attractions are a 
mental disorder 
(homophilia). The terms are 
distasteful to some people. 

Hormone therapy: Used to 
change secondary sex 
characteristics, including 


breast size, weight 
distribution, and facial hair 
growth. 


Identifyfied (as): To think of 
oneselfas having a particular 
sexual identity or gender 
identity (e.g. “l identify asa 
bisexual” or “He is bisexual- 
identified). To emphasise 
that an identity term refers 
to one’s internal reality, as 
opposed to what others 
perceive, 

Identity: How one thinks. of 
oneself. One's internal self, 
as Opposed to what others 
perceive, 

Kinsey scale, The: An cqual- 
interval scale with 
continuous graduations 
between heterosexuality (0) 
and homosexuality (6) used 
as a measure of sexuality. 

Label: How someone else sees 
or thinks of one. 

Lesbian: A woman who has 
Significant sexual and 


romantic attractions to 
members of the same sex, or 
who identifies as a member 
of the lesbian community. 
Bisexual women often do not 
feel included by this term. 

M2F: Male to female. Used to 
specify the direction cfa sex 
or gender role change. 

Monosexual: One who has 
significant sexual and 
romantic attractions 
primarily to members of one 
sex (i.e. straight, gay, 
lesbian).Someone whois not 
bisexual. 

Neuter: |. One who has neither 
a penis nor a vagina. 2. 
Occasionally used to mean 
androgynous. 

Other sex/gender: [he other 
sex or vender than the 
reference person’s own (¢.g. 
“She has an other sex 
partner”). 

(To be) Out: To be open about 
one’s sexual identity with 
someone or in a situation. 

(To) Out (someone): |. [0 
disclose a second person’s 
sexual identity to a third 
person, particularly without 
the second  person’s 
permission, 2. To disclose 
one’s own sexual identity, 
sometimes inadvertantly. 

Pre-operative transsexual 
(Pre-op TS): One who is 
actively planning to switch 
physical sexes, mostly to 
relieve gender dysphoria.. 
Probably, but not 
necessarily, cross dresses, 
takes hormone therapy, and 
gets electrolysis. 

Primary sex organs: Penis 
(male) or vagina (female). 
Queer: Reclaimed derogatory 
slang for the sexual minority 
community (e.g. Queer 
Nation), Not accepted by all 
the sexual minority 
community, especially older 

members, 

Same sex/gender: The same 
sex or gender as the 
reference person’s own (e.g. 
“She has a same sex 
partner”), 

Sex: male or female, depending 
onone’s primary sex organs, 

Sex role: See gender role. 

Sexual identity: How one 
thinks of oneself, in terms of 
being significantly attracted 
to members of the same or 
the other sex, Based on one’s 
internal experience, as 
opposed to which gender 
one’s sexual partners belong 
to. 

Sexual identity/minority 
community: A formal term 
which includes Jesbians, 


bisexuals, gays, and 
sometimes members of the 
gender community. 


Members of the sexual 
minoritycommunity usually 
do not identify as members 








of the gender community. 
Sexual orientation/ 
preference: Hoi one thinks 
of her/himself, in terms of 
being significantly attracted 
to members the same or the 
other sex. Sexual orientation 
implies the inability to 
control or influence the 
development of one’s sexual 
and romantic attractions, 
Conversely, sexual 
preference implies the 
ability to control or influence 
the development of one’s 
sexual and romantic 
attractions 
Sexual reassignment surgery 
(SRS): A surgical procedure 
which changes one’s primary 
sexual organs from one sex 
to another (i.e. penis to 
vagina or vagina to penis). 
Stonewall: A pivotal event in 
1969, which basically 
involved queers revolting 
against discrimination, that 
many attribute to having 
spurred the modern queer 
movement 
Straight: Colloquial for 
heterosexual, Because 
straight has connotations of 
“unadulterated,” “pure,” 
and “honest,” some 
members of the sexual 
identity community object 
to the implication that one 
who is not straightis “bent,” 
“adulterated,” “impure,” or 
“dishonest.” Straight has 
connotations of ‘narrow,’ 
‘straight-laced’ or 
‘conservative,’ and some 
heterosexual-identified 
people find it distasteful. 
Transgender community: 
Formal term for gender 
community. 
Transgendered (TG): One who 
switches gender roles, 
whether just once, or many 
times at will. Inclusive term 
for transsexuals and 
transvestites, 
Transsexual (TS): One who 
switches physical sexes 
(usually just once, but there 
are exceptions), Primary sex 
change is accomplished by 
sexual reassignment surgery, 


Hormone therapy, 
electrolysis, additional 
surgery, and other 
treatments that change 
secondary SCX 
characteristics, 


Transvestite (TV): One who 
mainly cross-dresses for 
pleasure in the appearance 
and sensation. The pleasure 
may not be directly erotic. 
May feel comfortable in a 
focused transgender role 
while cross dressed. May 
occasionally experience 
gender dysphoria. 


\ 4 ) THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 








LBGTM expands its 


By Roberta Laucke 


t Was only four years ago 
that queer McGill students 
created a new student-run 
service to ensure that their 
needs would be addressed. 
In 1991 the group was 


called Gays and Lesbians at : 


McGill. The group has since 
expanded its name to Lesbian, 
Bisexual, Gay and 
Transgendered Students of 
McGill (LBGTM) in order to 
include more members of the 
queer community rather than 
just gays and lesbians. 

“The role of LBGTM is to 
offer a safe space in and 
outside of McGill. It is a place 
to talk to people,” explained 
Sean Addis, | LBGTM’s 
administrator. 

“Here you can get to know 
people with the same concerns 
and political aspirations. You 
can receive counseling. We 
have dances and general 
discussion groups,” he 
continued, 

Many students at’ McGill 
have found the group 
extremely helpful in 
encouraging them to deal with 
their sexuality. This safe 
environment has made them 
feel comfortable to be 
themselves. 

“Tcame out my second year 
at McGill University. It’s nice 
knowing that something is out 
there... that we have a 
community and support so we 
do not feel alone,” stated 
Karen Tamaki, LBGTM's social 
co-coordinator. 

Membership numbers were 
low when the group first 
started, and the group 


expanded to include bisexuals 
during the 1992-1993 school 
year. Last summer a 
discussion group was held to 
make the group even more 
inclusive by adding 
transgendered people to the 
name, These changes were 
made to make all students 
feel welcome within the 
group. 

“Last year we discussed 
offering more space for 
everyone. In our constitution 
it states [that] we represent 
all issues and all people. We 
added transgendered people 
to make them feel included. 
The key is solidarity. We want 
transgendered people to feel 
accepted,” stated Addis. 

The group’s expansion has 
been beneficial to many 
students, “This expansion has 
made people address gender 
issues... There’s a lot more 
interest from women and 
trangendered people,” stated 
Chris Carter, political co- 
coordinator at LBGTM, 

“This has been beneficial 
for everyone. The main thing 
we wanted to do is raise 
awareness and we have,” he 
added. 

But even with these 
changes, some people still feel 
marginalised by LBGTM. 
“Most of the people who are 
active in the leadership of the 
group are men. Men have paid 
a lot of lip service in getting 
women involved... [but] it is 
the old boys’ network,” said 
Cherie Payne, a recent McGill 
graduate and past LBGTM 
member. 





community 


“I found 
membership the women’s 
level of involvement is low... 


There is definitely room for 


women to improve [their] 
Status in LBGTM,” Payne 
added. 

Tamaki agreed with Payne 
and stated that changes are 
necessary. “I thinkitis a tricky 
situation. There is separation 
between the men and the 
women because the group is 
male-dominated, so the 
women feel marginalised 
because theyare the minority. 
The general discussion group 
has 20 men and only three or 
four women. The situation can 
be improved.” 

According to Jeanna Steele, 
a U3 Arts student and past 
member of LBGTM, it is not 
only women but other groups 
who feel isolated as well. 

“Tfelt marginalised because 
[ am bisexual. I could not 
identify with the issues in the 
general discussion group. We 
had a separate group that was 
better. It identified more with 
bisexuals. I think itwould have 
been better if we had more 
group activities,” she said. 

Carter agreed with Steele, 
but stressed that the situation 


is slowly improving. “Lots of 


groups feel marginalised, 
[like] blacks, people of colour, 
bisexuals and women, [but] it 
is getting better. There have 
been problems with this 
situation and we are working 
on it,” he said. 

“Women in the past had 
low representation and we 
have addressed these issues. 


in terms of 


Now gender parity is required 
by the constitution for 
everything that LBGTM does. 
There are more women 
volunteers for higher 
positions. We are getting 
events at Sisters, the lesbian 
and bisexual bar. There has 
been the creation of the 


Women's group. The situation 


is improving,” he continued. 

LBGTM has also been trying 
to change policies at McGill. 
Members of the student-run 
Organisation feel the 
University is not sensitive to 
issues affecting the queer 
community. 

As such, LBGTM coordi- 
nators and Students’ Society 
VP University Affairs Lisa 
Grushcow have been working 
together on a questionnaire 
addressing problems of 
sexuality in relation to student 
life Seat? McGill. The 
questionnaire will be given out 
to students and faculty across 
campus exi semester. 

“The questionnaire will be 
modeled after the one 
Concordia gave out. We will 
be looking at heterosexuality 
and homophobia,” stated 
Grushcow. “We want to know 
if people are experiencing 
homophobia from peers and 
student services. We want to 
know if LBGT students are well 
served at McGill or if there is 
discrimination. We are looking 
for some direction to see what 
it is that we need to work on.” 

The questionnaire will 
provide specific facts to help 
McGill develop queer- 
sensitive policies and provide 


a safe space for everyone on 
campus. "Everyonc on campus 
should feel at home,” said 
Grushcow, but as of this 
moment not everyone docs. 
“Right now homosexuality 
is seen as a disease in some 
quarters. People are called 
‘faggots’ and people have been 
beaten up. We want 
homophobia, sexism and 
other forms of discrimination 
to be addressed in McGill’s 
harassment policies. These are 
student issues and we need to 
raise awareness,” she stated, 
Carter concurred with 
Grushcow. “McGill's 
administration is behind every 
other university on 
harassment and 
discrimination policies. There 
are no gay, lesbian, bisexual 
or transgendered policies. 


These issues have to be taken 


into consideration. There are 
benefits for opposite sex 
employees. There is nothing 
for the same sex.” 

Interested students can go to 
the following events: Bisexual 
group Wed. 17h30 pm, 
Shatner rm 423. Womyn's 
troup: Thurs. 18h Shatner 
425. Coming Out group Fri. 
[7h50 United Theological 
College at 3521 University. 
General Group Fri. 19h in 
the basement of the United 
Theological College. 
Coordinating committee 
mecting Wed, 18h30 Shatner 
455. There is also an LBGTM 
library available to all 
students. For more info: 398- 
6822, 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE ( 5 ) November 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


My DEGREE IS A SOURCE OF PRIDE. 
MY DIPLOMA FROM ITI IS A SOURCE OF 
Nee) =a 


Will Booth holds a B.Sc. ftom Acadia University and a diploma from ITI 
Will now works for Information Systems Management Corp., an IBM company. 





Er, MONTREAL’ S BEST RIDE SERVICE 


OTTAWA 








$12 


TORONTO $28 
QUEBEC St 


LONDON $40 





and others... 


¢ PRICES PER PASSENGER (ONE Ne 
¢ PASSENGERS. &-DRIVERS WELCOM 


987-9615 


92 SHERBROOKE W. MONTREAL 


421A QUEEN ST, W. #2 TORONTO 


(416) 977-4572. - 





FREE MEMBERSHIP FOR McGILL STUDENTS WITH THIS AD! (1D REQUIRED) 


| STEWART ST..#200 OTTAWA 
(613) 565-7531 


NEWYORK $45 





De ART TE i, | 





4 ‘ IRS : 
; A Di SE : 
esp NE TES 24 





Information 
Technology 
Institute 


YOUR SPRINGBOARD TO 


SUCCESS IN THE NEW ECONOMY. 


You've got a university degree. But you know you 
could be doing so much more with it than you are 
@ right now. You'd like a challenging, well-paying job 
4 witha future. If this sounds familiar...you owe it to 
* yourself to look into ITI. 
: Ottawa‘ Information Technology Institute — or ITI - 
offers a unique 9-month program that takes university 
__ grads from a broad range of backgrounds and gives 
them the information technology training that today’s 
~ companies are looking for. 
It's a proven program. Find out more about it today. 


CALL FOR A BROCHURE, OR TO 
REGISTER FOR OUR FREE 
INFORMATION SEMINAR: | 

1-800-939-4484 | 


Program includes courses in Novell, UNIX, 
Visual Basic, Oracle, PowerBuilder, Object 
Oriented Design and Analysis, and much more. 





$10 for him 
680 Sherbrooke 


(corner University, next to McGill) | 


1844-9688 WITH THIS AD! 





SALON RALPH 


Women’s & Men's Hair Stylists 


Perm $2 


| 

with coupon | 
Shampoo, cut, | 
| 

| 








wash, & blow dry 


15 for her 








Starting 


By Jacqueline Reis 





In 1991, the Québec Human 
Rights Commission found that 
there was an atmosphere of 
homophobia at McGill. 

Raynald Lepage, president 
of Lesbian and Gay Employ- 
ees of McGill (LAGEM) re- 
counted one instance in which 
“A supervisor told an e@m- 
ployee that had that person 
known thatthe employee was 
gay, he would have never been 
hired.” 

He added, “It was a com- 
ment that went a long way.” 

When asked about McGill's 
response to discrimination on 
the basis of sexual orienta- 
tion, Sean Addis, administra- 
tor of Lesbian, Bisexual, Gay 
and Transgendered students 
of McGill (LBGTM), said “I 
think it’s an issue that they 
Lry to neglect. [Us something 
that they try to blind sight... 
[But] we know that it’s 
present.” 

Addis cited the events sur- 
rounding a recent LBGTM 
dance at Gert’s as one exam- 
ple. According to Addis, many 
of the people who were in the 
bar before the dance made 
homophobic comments and 
POSLUTCS, 

“Sometimes people don't 
say much, but it is present,” 
said Addis. 

“I’ve heard a lot of stories 
and I believe a lot of stories,” 
said Lisa Grushcow, Students’ 
Sociely vp university affairs, 
Grushcow listed several forms 
of heterosexism on campus, 
including gay bashing, 
homophobic slurs and a cur- 
riculum that teaches homo- 
sexuality as a deviation. 

“It happens,” said Chris 
Carter, a political coordina- 
tor alLBGTM, referring to dis- 
crimination on the basis of 
sexual orientation. “A 
proactive administration on 
this issue would be great.” 

But when asked if he ex- 
pected to see this happen, his 
response was “In a word, no,” 


Where's the policy? 

The words “sexual orienta- 
tion” are mentioned only once 
in the entire forest of paper 
work that makes up McGill 
policy. 

“Every student has a right 
to equal treatment by the 
University; this right must not 
be impaired by discrimina- 
tion based on race, colour, 
ethnic or national origin, civil 
status, religion, creed, politi- 
cal conviction, language, sex, 
sexual orientation, social con- 
dition, age, personal handi- 
cap” ete. (Charter of Students’ 





Novemser 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 





Rights, Part 1, 2.1). 

This excerpt applies only 
to students. Faculty members 
fall under McGill’s equity 
policy: “McGill University is 
committed toemployment eq- 
uity and in particular to pro- 
viding equal employment op- 
portunities consistent with the 
provisions of the Québec 
Charter of Human Rights and 
Freedoms and the Canadian 
Charter of Rights and 
lrecdoms.” 

Honora Shaughnessy, di- 
rector of the Employment 
Equity Office, said that Eq- 
uity does not have a spe- 
cific mandate to deal with 
issues of discrimination on 
the basis of sexual orienta- 
lion. 

“Noone has ever come to 
me specifically complain- 
ing [about] sexual orienta- 
tion... The Equity Office 
doesn’t have a mandate,” 
she said, adding that no 
equity office in Canada 
does. “That's just the way it 
is.” 

According to the office 
of the principal and vice- 
principals, Shaughnessy is 
the administration’s 
spokesperson on this issue, 

Fortunately for staff 
members, the Quebec Char- 
ter was the first human 
rights document in Canada 
lo specifically entrench the 
right to freedom from dis- 
crimination on the basis of 
sexual orientation. 

McGill’s scanty policies 
on this issue are considered 
inadequate by members of 
both the student and faculty 
communities. 


from scratch 


Groups work toward 


sexual orientation policy 


“T haven't kind of grouped 
harassment on the basis on 
any of those things, but there 
continue to be a number of 
students who will bring these 
issues forth, in terms of either 
remarks faculty or teachers 
made that they find offensive,” 
said Estelle Hopmeyer, 
ombudsperson for students. 

“] think it would be very 
helpful if there was a more 
[comprehensive] policy on any 
kind of harassment,” she 
added. 


‘I know 
from hav- 
ing talked 

to other 
universi- 
ties, McGill 
is behind 
the times,” 

Sean Addis, admin- 
istrator of Lesbian, 
Bisexual, Gay and 
Transgendered stu- 
dents of McGill 
(LBGTM). 






” 


“There is no official policy, 
said Carter. “To have it worded 
out, specifically, would make 
sure someone goes ahead [with 
filing a grievance].” 

Addis commented that “A 
lot of times LBGT issues are 
neglected, are put to the side... 
I know from having talked to 
other universities, McGill is be- 
hind the times.” 


Good for a trip to the den- 

tist, but... 

One measure of an institution's 
attitude toward homosexu- 
ality is the extent to which 
itoffersitsemployees same- 
sex benefits. 

According to Lepage, 
McGill extends monetary 
benefits, such as Medicare 
and the dental plan, to 
Same-Sex spouses as per the 
Québec Charter. 

To qualify for these 
rights, the employee and 
his/her partner must meet 
the same standards a com- 
mon-law heterosexual cou- 
plewould, thatis, they must 
have lived together for 
three years. Lepage men- 
tioned that a letter is ad- 
equate proof of this. 

However, McGill does not 
extend same-sex benefits in 
terms of time if an employ- 
ee’s partner becomes sick 
or if one of their in-laws 
dies. 

“To me, being gay is be- 
ing human, and! don’t see 
why we should be denied 
what has been granted to 
everyone,” said Lepage. “It’s 
inconsiderable that some 
kinds [of people] would be 
denied the right to funeral 

rights,” 

Lepage added that LAGEM is 

not a highly visible organisa- 





tion on campus (the Daily 
talked to several people who 
were not sure it still existed). 

“We are made up of people 
involved in various organisa- 
tions anyway,” said Lepage, 
who keeps a list of phone num- 
bers to help members find as- 
sistance. 

“We don’t feel the need of 
making a big display,” he con- 
cluded. 

Making “a big display” is 
particularly difficult when 
your members don’t always 
want to be seen. Lepage would 
not say how many members 
LAGEM has and mentioned 
that it is often easier for stu- 
dents to ‘come out’ than em- 
ployees. 

“The younger people are 
much more confident, and 
there are more resources for 
them to know that they are not 
alone,” said Lepage. “Employ- 
ees tend to keep a low profile. 
Usually, if they get along with 
people, they might open up, 
but they keep it very quiet... 

“You don’t give any lead to 
it, but you don’t deny or con- 
firm,” he added. “I think the 
higher they go into the hierar- 
chy, especially at McGill, the 
less you're going to hear about 
its. 


Taking action 

Students at McGill are taking 
steps to find out to what ex- 
tent the “atmosphere of 
homophobia” still exists at 
McGill and how it can be ad- 
dressed. 

Members of LBGTM and the 
Students’ Society plan to ask 
students to fill out a question- 
naire about heterosexism on 
campus, 

“McGill’s behind the times 
in a lot of things,” said Addis. 
“Now it’s time to just show the 
Dean of Students, this is what 
we got through our question- 
naire.... It’s an actual fact, it’s 
not just people whining.” 

Addis and Grushcow hope 
that the questionnaire will give 
students and administrators 
specific areas on which to fo- 
cus, like residence life, Stu- 
dent Services, the Students’ 
Society or course curricula. 

“I think we need a policy 
and I think we need to get 
directions,” said Grushcow. 

Grushcow expects the ques- 
tionnaires to be available at 
tables around campus in the 
third week in January. 


For more information on Les- 
bian and Gay Employees of 
McGill (LAGEM), call Raynald 
Lepage at 398-4711, or write 
to LAGEM, c/o Raynald Lepage, 
Department of Rare Books, 
McLennan Library. 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 











= Worried about dp 


Harris cuts hit queer com- 


EL a ~ 





by Idella Sturino 





Ithough Ontario Pre- 
A mier Mike Harris has 

taken no official stance 

on gay and lesbian 
rights in the province, recent 
decisions made by the Harris 
government have members of 
the queer community wonder- 
ing, 

A decision not to re-intro- 
duce legislation to give same- 
sex couples equal benefits as 
opposite-sex couples — an ini- 
tiative the Rae government 
tried unsuccessfully — seems 
to reflect the Harris govern- 
ment’s general attitude. 

“(Same sex benefits are) not 
a priority for the government, 
not something they were 
elected on,” said David Lan- 
caster, a special assistant to 
Rosedale Conservative MPP Al 
Leach, the attorney-general. 

Asimilar decision was made 
in July, when the government 
decided to pull out of a court 
challenge initiated by the pre- 
vious NDP government against 
the federal Income Tax Act. 
The intervention was made on 
behalf of the Canadian Union 
of Public Employees, which 
argued that the Act’s defini- 
tion of spouse was unconstitu- 
tional because it referred to 
heterosexual couples only. 

In addition, the government 
recently reversed the prov- 
ince’s position on a ruling on 


the provincial Fam- 
ily Law Act. Marian 
Boyd, then attorney- 
general, had tried 
unsuccessfully to 
change the Act’s 
definition of spouse 
to include same-sex |". 
couples and later ar- | =) 


gued that the defi- AOR RS AE oats aye ES 


nition, left un- 
changed, was un- 
constitutional be- 
cause it discrimi- |@ 
nated on the |i 
grounds of sexual [84 
orientation. The Rae |e 
government had | 
submitted its oppo- | 
sition as an 
intervenor in a civil 
action suit. How- 
ever, a Harris gov- 
ernment 


the law’s validity as 
itstands in asubmission to the 
court in September, 

Other ominous signs that 
affect Ontarians both within 
and outside the queer com- 
myinity include cuts to social 
services, cooperative housing 
and community-based centres, 

Micheal Shapcott of the Co- 
operative Housing Association 
of Ontario talks about the re- 
cent Harris decision to kill 385 
new subsidised housing 


* # 
lawyer, 
Robert Charney, ef- 
fectively sided with 





projects, including a gay and 
lesbian co-op in Toronto. Ac- 
cording to Shapcott, these 
kinds. of housing initiatives 
have been particularly impor- 
tant for gays and lesbians. Like 
single mothers, people of col- 
our and people with disabili- 
ties, “gays and lesbians have 
long been marginalised by the 
private housing market and 
the only good housing for them 
has been co-op housing,” 





Shapcott said, 

He added that com- 
munity initiatives 
within co-ops have set 
aside many of the ex- 
isting units for people 
living with AIDS. 
Those who did not 
f find housing under 
these initiatives, how- 
ever, Will have a diffi- 
cult time finding ad- 
equate housing be- 
cause of a July deci- 
sion to freeze the con- 
struction of new units. 

“What (the Harris 
government) has 
) done is frozen exist- 
ing stock, and there's 
no hope they'll be new 
stock in coming years 
for the growing de- 
mand, which is very 
strong,” said Shapcott. 

In addition to cuts 
to housing, hospitals 
and special health services, the 
government recently an- 
nounced.a $1.7 million cut to 
an HIV assistance programme 
and a further $77 000 
trimmed from an AIDS pre- 
vention and control program. 
While these cuts affect all 
Ontarians, the proportion of 
people living with AIDS is 
higher among the gay male 
community than within. the 
province as a whole, However, 


munity hard 


the group that is currently 
contracting AIDS at the fast- 
est rate is general population 
between the ages of 18 and 
25. 

Harris’ cuts may hit people 
living with AIDS the hardest. 
Finance Minister David 
Tsbouchi’s infamous $90-a- 
month diet, for example, is 
not adequate for anyone, let 
alone someone living with an 
illness like AIDS and has spe- 
cial nutritional needs. Accord- 
ing to advocates, poverty is a 
reality for many people living 
with AIDS. 

Cuts to community centres 
may also have an impact on 
AIDS-related services, In early 
October, the government an- 
nounced a total of $6.3 mil- 
lion in cuts to neighbourhood 
community-based centres, ef- 
fective as of Januaryl. Sev- 
eral of these centres have had 
up to 80 per cent of their 
funding cut. Many provide 
AIDS-related services, suchas 
outreach, counseling and pre- 
ventative education, 

Summarising the effects of 
the Harris cuts, Toronto City 
Councilor Kyle Rae told eye 
weekly magazine earlier this 
month, “The Tory govern- 
ment doesn'tcare about street 
youth, HIV-positive youth, the 
poor or the City of Toronto.” 


Inching their way out of the mainstream 


by Sonia Verma 





usual in September. 

This year, the 
Toronto Board of Education 
launched an innovative pro- 
gramme to specifically address 
the educational and emotional 
needs of gay and lesbian youth. 

The Triangle Programme 
provides an alternative school 
for students aged 16-21 who 
have experienced physical or 
emotional abuse in main- 
stream schools because of their 
sexual orientation. 

“The Triangle Programme 
is designed to respond to the 
failure of mainstream schools 
to beinclusive,” explained John 
Campey, an openly gay To- 
ronto School Board Trustee 
who helped to initiate the pro- 
gramme, 

It is hoped that the pro- 
gramme will offer vulnerable 
students a refuge from the 
homophobia and harassment 
present in mainstream schools. 
“These kids have endured ver- 
bal harassment, been beaten- 
up and have been denied rep- 
resentation in the curriculum,” 
Campey explained. 

The Triangle Programme is 
one of several specialty schools 
opened as an extension of the 


ot all Toronto students 
N went back to school as 


Oasis alternative schools pro- 
gramme. Oasis was created 
under the Rae government 
(1990-1995) in order to ac- 
commodate students who have 
fallen out of the mainstream 
system. The schools offer spe- 
cialised curricula based on spe- 
cific needs of individual stu- 
dents. 

This existing institutional 
framework meant that the Tri- 
angle Programme and the 
Nighana Programme that ad- 
dresses the needs of black stu- 
dents were initiated with little 
difficulty. The implementation 
of these programmes was Car- 
ried out on an exclusively ad- 
ministrative level in order to 
avoid a potential right-wing 
backlash. 

The classes, which are lim- 
ited to 25 students and one 
teacher each, focus on indi- 
vidual learning and independ- 
ent study. Supporters of the 
Triangle Programme say that 
gay and lesbian students’ spe- 
cificneeds are more effectively 
addressed in a student- 
friendly learning environment 


than in what Campey called 


the “educational factory” of 
mainstream schools. 
But some critics of the pro- 


Separate classes for gays 
and lesbians in Toronto 


gramme claim that it may do 
more harm than good. They 
say it isolates gay and lesbian 
students by placing them on 
the periphery of the greater 
student body. 

The programme is not in- 
tended to actively segregate 
students. Those who have en- 
rolled are unable to cope in 
mainstream schools. Many had 
dropped out or had been frus- 
trated enough to consider it. 
The Triangle Programme is 
designed to offer them a 
choice. 

The programme provides 
these students with an oppor- 
tunity to succeed in a gay- 
positive environment. Classes 
are taught by an openly gay 
teacher in a space donated by 
the Metropolitan Community 
Church, which has a large gay 
congregation. 

David Rayside, vice-presi- 
dent of University College and 
founder of the University of 
Toronto’s Committee on 
Homophobia maintained, “It 


is not an attempt to take peo- 
ple out of school, it is a transi- 
tionary stage aimed at people 
who have already dropped out 
of school.” 

Rayside, however, acknowl- 
edged that the reintegration 
of Triangle Programme stu- 
dents is an important chal- 
lenge. “It is a difficult issue. It 
may be hard to re-integrate 
these students when they 
leave such a secure environ- 
ment,” he said. 

There is also the risk that 
creating separate classes for 
gays and lesbians will reduce 
the pressure for mainstream 
schools to accommodate the 
needs of marginalised stu- 
dents. 

However, both Campey and 
Rayside argued the contrary. 
“The programme makes gay 
and lesbian issues more vis- 
ible, creating a higher aware- 
ness right across the board,” 
Campey said. 

The Triangle Programme is 
only one elementinaseries of 


curricular and policy reforms 
executed by the Toronto 
Board of Education to reflect 
the diverse educational needs 
of its students. Changes in 
curriculum, an inclusive 
sexual harassment policy, sup- 
port groups and equity work 
represent a significant reas- 
sessmentof less accommodat- 
ing Board procedures. 

Because the programme is 
still in its initial phases, the 
impact of students returning 
to mainstream schools and, 
toa greater extent, the overall 
success of the programme 
won’t be known for years to 
come. 

According to Campey, com- 
prehensive change as demon- 
strated by the Triangle pro- 
gramme has been “quite suc- 
cessful.” However, the fight 
for gay and lesbian rights in 
the school system is still an 
uphill battle. “Change tends 
to occur in inches,” Rayside 
commented, 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE ( 7 ) NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


a Coming to grips with diversity 


by Melanie Newton 





he Gay and Lesbian 

Community Centre of 

Montréal. The Gay and 
Lesbian Film Festival. Diffusion 
gaic et lesbienne. Association 
gaie et lesbienne d'UQAM. 

Once upon a time, 
organisations like the ones 
listed above stood out as 
symbols of queer unity and 
activism. Now they are just as 
noticeable forsomething which 
they don’t say — bisexual. 

Many activists see this 
omission of bisexuals as a 
reflection of ignorance about 
bisexuality at best, and blatant 
biphobia (prejudice against 
bisexuals) at worst. 

“There’s a sort of classic 
argument that bisexuals only 
need recognition in so far as 
they are gay. The other 
[straight] aspect of their 
personality is covered by the 
greater society and we don’t 
need to cater to that,” says 
David D’Andrea, facilitator of 
LBGTM’s bisexual discussion 
group, 

According to D’Andrea the 
term “gay” once genuinely 
included all non-heterosexuals. 
llowever, as the movement 
gained strength there was a 
move toexclude “embarrassing 
elements” -- like feminists, 
bisexuals and transgendered 
people -- from the struggle. 

LBGTM'S Political 
Coordinator Chris Carter says 
this neglect has limited the 


ee nimes sn ee = ms ee 


number of services 
to bisexuals. 

“Discussion groups, 
support groups, bars, 
magazines are not available 
to bisexuals. The Montréal 
community has never done 
political action directly 
pertaining to bisexuals at all,” 
says Carter. 

Controversy surrounded last 
year’s Divers/Cité march, 


catering 


Montréal’s gay pride pass 


when Ki Namaste, 
the only bisexual or 
transgendered 
person scheduled 
to speak, was cut 
from the 
programme at the 
last minute. 


groups, these [older] people 
didn’t come of age in a time 
when bisexuality was an issue. 
They don’t understand it...,” 
says D'Andrea. 

The lack of bi-positive 
organisations places 
overwhelming pressure on the 
few that exist. Montréal 
bisexuals lost an important 
forum this year with, the 
demise of Bi-The- -Way! the 


city's only other. bisexual 


“just as $ lesbians and: gay men ™ 23) 
refuse the narrow options of. 
compulsory heterosexuality, we 


services are available from one 
year to the next. But given 
that Québec’s queer 
community is allegedly the 
province’s largest minority 
group, these points don’t fully 
explain the absence of a 
bisexual movement in 
Montréal. 

Another explanation may 
be the lack of communication 
between campus queer 
organisations — where most 

of the 

movement’s 
OL 
theoretical 
issues are 
discussed — 
and the wider 
Montréal 


Carter pointsto refuse to be trapped by ahetero/ community. 
the Image and i And then 
Nation Gay and’ homo man/woman split.” — there is the 
Lesbian Film language 
Festival; organised ‘Bisexual and transgender, activist. divide. Chantal, 


by Diffusions gaic 
etlesbienne,as one 
of the few non- 
university queer 
events which deals with 
bisexual issues. 


Explaining the silence 
Why are there so few services 
for queer people and why has 
no bisexual movement 
developed here? 

D’Andrea says there is an 
age division across North 
America’s queer movement. 

“Certainly in a lot of gay 


Ki Namaste... 





discussion group besides 
LBGTM’s. 

Bi-The-Way facilitator 
Caroline Coté had to end the 
group because of the 
enormous strain on the 
yroup’s organisers. Côté 
looked for someone to take it 
over, but could find no one 
willing. 

The constant turn-over 
makes it hard to know what 


a francophone 
“bisexual and a 
feOnrameenr 
Université de 
Montréal student explains, 
“You’d have to be an 
anglophone student to find 
out about [LBGTM’s bisexual 
discussion group]....” 
Recently, queer groups at 
French and English universities 
and CEGEPs in Montréal tried 
to form a Queer Federation. 
But language problems and the 
issue of bisexuality ultimately 
contributed to the plan’s 


THE BISEXUALITY DEBATE IN MONTREAL 


failure. 

According to Carter, one of 
the francophone organisations 
was unwilling to include 
bisexual rights in the 
federation’s Constitution. 


Signs of the timesat McGill 
In 1992, the Gays and Lesbians 
of McGill (GALOM) was one of 
the city’s first organisations to 
change its name to include 
bisexuals, becoming the 
Lesbians, Bisexuals and Gays of 
McGill. To overcome biphobia 
and sexism, LBGM also 
introduced a non- 
discrimination clause in their 
Constitution. 

This year the name was 
changed again to Lesbian, 
Bisexual, Gay and Transgender 
Students of McGill. 

“It’s unmistakable that it’s 
getting better just in the few 
years that I’ve been at McGill. 
But it used to be accepted to 
question, within LBGM (then 
called GALOM), whether 
bisexuals actually exist and 
whether we need to accept 
them,” says D’Andrea. 

According to D'Andrea, the 
bisexual discussion group was 
also started “because, if you go 
to the general discussion group, 
it’s mainly homosexual as 
opposed to bisexual...” 

Opinion differs on how 
LBGTM’s reforms have changed’ 
gay and lesbian members’ 
attitudes towards bisexuality. 





A MARRIAGE OF CONVENIENCE 


by Karen Tamaki and Chris Carter 





any suggest that the 

lesbian, gay, 

bisexual, and 
transgender community is 
merely a 
convenience, a temporal 
community united by the 
pursuit of a few common goals 
and our status as second class 
citizens. 

But some, like Peter Wallet, 
an LBGTM facilitator, believe 
this union is necessary. 

“We [lesbian, bisexual, gay 
and transgender people] 


should take other groups 
under our wings,” stated 
Wallet. 


“Weare all not liked, we are 
all discriminated against and 


we all have to deal with gender 


and sexuality issues,” he 
added, 

However, because 
discrimination is so pervasive 
throughout society, it is 
inevitably a part of the queer 


community. 


In interviewing students, . 
saw. this sort Of: 


many. 


marriage of 


segregation manifested in 
community bars and 
discussion groups. Chris M, 
peer support  referral 
coordinator of LBGTM, noted 
“There is segregation with 
clubs. Even supposedly mixed 
clubs are dominated by men. 
Therefore, women prefer to 
go to women-only clubs.” 

The desire for segregated 
groups can also be found in 
the organisation of LBGTM’s 
social groups, which recently 
added a women’s group due to 
the large percentage of menin 
the general discussion group. 
Is this reinforcing the gap 
between men and women? 

Chris M. saw this 
segregation as inappropriate. 
But Wallet explained that, 
“Women area neglected sector 
of society. [Discussion groups] 
provide a forum solely 
concerning [women’s] issues. 
Sexism is inherent in the gay 
community, 
unavoidable dite to our 
society.’ ane 


Novemser 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


and it is. 


Meredith Cohen, an LBGTM 
general discussion group 
facilitator, added to this 
sentiment. 

“It is not that lesbians [and 
bisexual women] are 
uncomfortable around gay 
[and bisexual] men or vice 
versa, it’s just that women feel 
strange ifthey walkintoa club 
or room that is dominated by... 
the opposite sex.” 

Cohen continued to 
acknowledge that sexism, 
misogyny and male-bashing is 
a problem within the 
community. She said, however, 
“I don’t expect to walk up to 
gay men and have them be 
sexist. It’s notaspecial problem 
within our. community. 
Comparing ourselves to other 
factions, we are much more 
healthy. We have all gone 
through an analysis of 


ourselves, ourcommunity, and: 
the world in which we live, 


and we are therefore much 
better at understanding these 


~~ elements, Therefore, we expect 


amore enlightened view (from 
queer people],” 

For Hannah Rogers, a 
political coordinator at 
LBGTM, the separation 
between men and women in 
forums such as discussion 
groups is notso mucha matter 
of sexism as a lack of common 
interests, 

“|The rift between men and 
women] partly is a result of 
sexism, and partly it’s due to 
the fact that gay men and 
lesbians have few common 
interests, What do lesbians and 
gay men really have in 
common?” — 

Rogers went on to note that 
she often felt like a token 
female offering opinions on 
gay male issues at the general 
discussion group 

“The women’s groupis there 
because women specifically 
wanted a group. If men wanted 


one, there would be a men’s 


group. It's not a matter of 


segregation. LBGTM speaks to 
the needs of the people in its 


The rift between men and women in the queer community 


organisation,” said Sean Addis, 
LBGTM’s administrator. 

“We're trying to meet 
everyone’s concerns. It’s the 
same as the bisexual group. 
We still have the general group 
as an option for the entire 
community to DERE 
together.” 

Addis noted that the most 
important thing is to provide 
a safe environment for all 
members. He also pointed out 
thattheinclusionofawomen's 
group in LBGTM has definitely 
increased the female 
membership, as Was 
demonstrated by the high 
proportion of women (over 50 
per cent) at LBGTM’s most 
recent dance at Gert's. 

As a community composed 
of people of all races, religions, 
and genders, it is necessary to 
recognise differences. 
However, as gender roles 
become less rigidly defined, it 
is increasingly true that 


everyone's issues are creryone 
else's issues, - skh madi | 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL SUE 








i 
? 


pr “on 


—_—" = — ne 


._ 





Jen Mooney, a bisexual, said 
her experience has been good. 
“It was really, really positive, 
very accepting — no pressure 
to say that! was biorstraight or 
lesbian,” said Mooney. 

Eric, a 20 year old student 
who neither defines himself as 
bisexual nor straight, feels 
differently. He agrees that 
LBGTM has changed a lot but 
finds that they have catered to 
stereotypes and have “played 
down diversity.” 


Weredowegofromhere? 
Most people agree that the 
movement has made some steps 
forward on the issue of 
bisexuality, but say more must 
be done. 

D'Andrea says there have 
been bi-positive improvements 
to Montréal’s queer services, 
particularly help-lines for 
people who are questioning 
their sexuality or just need to 
talk about it, 

But D’Andrea is critical of 
the queer Montréal media, 
Which he says is “not really 
cognizant of diversity.” 

Meanwhile, John Rioux of 
the Gay and Lesbian 
Community Centre of Montréal 
(CCGLM), the only one of its 
bind in tha city elaime that 


A LURDIL clin. Lees LUE, LU bea 
that, within the community, 
there is diversity.” 

However, some sce the 
CCGLM as unwilling to 
represent the whole 
community. 

“Last year, a friend of mine 
asked a representative of the 
CCGLM specifically what their 
line on bisexuality was. [The 
representative] said he doesn’t 
think that bisexuality exists, 
that you’re either gay or 
Straight,” says bisexual 
Concordia student Tamara 
Vukov. 

D'Andrea says more queer 
Organisations need to accept 
responsibility for addressing 
bisexual issues. He sees open 
discussion, with knowledgeable 
bisexuals present, as a 
necessary first step. In Carter’s 
opinion, more organisations 
should take a “zero tolerance” 
stand against biphobia. 

In the speech which she was 
to read at Divers/Cité, 
Montréaler Ki Namaste says “... 
As bisexuals and 
transgenders... [w]e do not just 
offer new or different names to 
call oneself. 

“We pose a fundamental 
challenge to the ways in which 
gender and sexuality are 
organised in this society. Just as 
lesbians and gay men refuse the 
narrow options of compulsory 
heterosexuality, we refuse to be 
trapped by ahetero/homo man/ 
woman split.” 


GETTING THE BALL ROLLING és 


Lesbian presence felt at world 
conference on women 


by Anup Grewal 





n Sept. 8, women 

sitting through a key 

plenary session at the 
UN Beijing Conference on 
Women were confronted bya 
banner reading “Lesbian 
Rights are Human Rights.” 

The plenary ground to a 
halt and guards quickly 
removed the disruptors — 
lesbian participants — who had 
wanted to call attention to the 
lesbian presence at the 
conference. 

This event is telling of the 
dynamics played out in both 
the Non-Governmental 
Organisations conference in 
Huairou, Chinaand the official 
conference in Beijing. Women 
from more than 189 countries 
gathered for the first two weeks 
in September to discuss the 
Platform for Action, hailed by 
many as a groundbreaking 
document for recognising the 
diverse lives of women 
everywhere. 

But as the conference drew 
to a close in the wee hours of 
Sept. 15, a much-anticipated 
clause recognising the right to 
sexual orientation was deleted 
from the Platform because 
more than 30 countries 
remained in opposition to it. 

While this was a 
disappointment for lesbians 
and other women, some felt 
that all was not lost. Julie Dorf 


Lesbian Human Rights 
Commission in San Fransisco 
commented on the important 
achievements in terms of 
visibilityand participation that 
lesbian women made at the 
conferences. “No one who was 
at either conference could have 
been there without thinking 
about sexual orientation,” she 
stated. mo 


Canadian initiative 

The inclusion of the term 
sexual orientation:was a point 
of debate from the start: 
Canada had introduced the 
term at the final preparatory 


meeting for the’ Beijing” 


conference in New York at the 

end of April. | 
Sheila Reghr of Status of 

Women Canada said that this 


is “entirely consistent with. 
voices like Hayes’. were 
definitely a minority at the 
conference. Dorf remained» 


Canadian policy.” 

According to Reghr, Canada 
requested a “descriptive 
paragraph [which included the 
term sexual orientation] to 
recognise women’s diversity” 
in the conference’s Platform. 
This request was supported 
by the 54 countries of the 
Economic Commission of 
Europe. 

However, there was not 
enough time to discuss the 
inclusion of sexual orientation, 
so the Commission put the 
term in brackets in four places 
in the document, leaving the 
decision for the actual 
conference. 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 





According to one Canadian 
official quoted in the Globe 
and Mail Sept.9, the fact that 
“sexual orientation” was not 
included is not surprising: 
“Recognition of this form of 
discrimination is not an easy 
one for many countries.” 

Yet, as Reghr pointed out, 
Canadaand 30 other countries, 
including the European Union 
nations, Australia, Cuba, Israel, 
Slovenia and South Africa 
supported including the term 
“sexual orientation.” This, 


also been at the Nairobi 
women’s conference in 1985, 
was “outstanding,” 

These nations all added 
supplementary clauses to the 
conference report stating that 
in their individual countries 
they will recognise sexual 
orientation as unacceptable 
grounds for discrimination. 


Give and take 

There was some disagreement 
Within the Canadian 
delegation. Sharon Hayes, a 
Reform MP who attended the 
conference, left early. “I was 
perturbed by Canada’s 
support during the conference 
for defining. women’s sexual 


rights, including the right to 


choose their. sexual 


orientation.” 


But, according to Dorf, 


positive. “We did not manage 


to retain the language, but we. 


did manage to have a full 
discussion 


end of the conference.” 

Dorf added that the vocal 
lesbian presence at the 
conferences aided the “radical 
end of the progressive parts of 
the document” and allowed 
unprecedented measures to be 
adopted. 

Pointing toa clause defining 
women’s rights, Dorf said, 
“There were positive gains on 


“on sexual. 
orientation for one houratthe 


sexual autonomy. We can do 
what we want with our bodies: 
we have the right to say ‘no’.” 

The clause Dorf refered to 
asserts that women’s human 
rights include the rights to 
control and decide matters 
related to their sexuality, free 
from coercion, discrimination 
or violence. There is also a 
clause which notes that 
“various forms of the family 
exist.” 

lor Rachel Rosenbloom, also 
of the International Gay and 


Commission, this clause is 
“very good.” In an October 
interview with the Advocate, 
Rosenbloom said she was 
hopeful thatlesbian rights will 
be recognised at the next UN 
women’s conference. The 
trend seems to be positive: At 
the Nairobi conference in 
1985, only one nation openly 


- supported lesbian rights, while 


over 30 did in Beijing. 

In the meantime, Dorf hailed 
the opportunity the Beijing 
conference provided for 
lesbians to network and 
educate. Dorf said she was 
“pleased with the large lesbian 
caucus, as wells as the 
demonstrations and the tent 
lesbian women were given to 
hold any events they wanted. 
There were only seven of these 
“diversity tents” and lesbian 
organisers, who had lobbied 


for one all year; were 


encouraged by the fact.tha 
they were given one. | 

According to Dorf, the tent 
was “constantly filled,” with 
ad-hoc workshops and social 
events, 2 
~ “It was such a place for an 
exchange of ideas and there 
were many women who came 
just because they wanted to 
know more about lesbians,” 
she said. 

Dorf added that it was 
“inspiring to have organised 
Our visibility with such 
minimal opposition.” 

“We left excited about the 


presence of and solidarity for 
lesbians in the women's 
movement,” commented Dorf. 


Impossible to ignore 

For Dorf, the dynamics at the 
Beijing conference reflect the 
changes in the women's 
movementinthelastien years. 
Despite the presence of such 
individuals as Hayes and 
continued opposition from 
Orthodox Catholic and 
orthodox Islamic 
representatives, Dort asserted 


show overt lesbophobia.” 

She explained that “There 
are still some clear difficulties 
with homophobia in the 
women’s movement, but it is 
changing. It was pretty 
amazing how the couple of 
incidents of intolerance were 
ignored, were hissed at: It was 
not an okay position.” 

Dorf said that the 
-involvementoflesbian women 
in reproductive health work, 
peace work and women’s issues 
makes it difficult to ignore 
women’s right to express their 
sexual orientation. 

She noted that another 
important development is the 
internationalisation of the 
lesbian movement. 

The International Gay and 
Lesbian Human Rights 
Commission released a 
document at the conference 
entitled “Unspoken Rules: 
Sexual Orientation and 


~ Women’s Human Rights.” This 


is a compilation of stories by 
31 lesbian women, from as 
many countries, documenting 
lesbian life and 
marginalisation around the 
world, 

It is no longer only North 
American or European lesbian 
women who are speaking out. 
Pointing to the growing voice 
of African, Asian and Latin 
American lesbians, Dorf said 
that it is becoming 
“impossible” to ignore their 
presence. 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 











© CHALLENGING TH 


by Derek Fung 


An inte 


aggi Rubenstein is a sex 


ologist and dean of stu 


| L dents at the Institute. for. 

the Advanced Study of Sexuality i in. 
San Francisco. She was also one of 
the first people to Speak out on | 


bisexual issues. 


In 1976, Rubenstein co founded: 


San Francisco’s BiCenter with Harriet 


Levy and David Laurier. It.was the 


first centre devoted - but not lim- 
ited to - bisexuals. There was world- 


wide interestin and support for this. 


ground-breaking community cen- . 


tre, which was the first to provide 

counseling services to bisexuals. . 
When the rise of AIDS in the early 

‘80s forced many people back into 


the closet, the BiCenter:lost a size- 


able proportion of its membership. 


_. Larger community centres and sup-. 


port groups, having begun to recog- 


nise the existence of bisexuals; ex 
panded to meet their needs.:The: 
BiCenter eventually closed down in. 
1984 due to financial problems and 


volunteer burn- ~out. 


In 1987, Rubenstein par ticipated 
in the creation of the Bay Area Bi-* 


sexual Network after an inspirational’. 

meeting with the East Coast* 
BiNetwork. Today, the BABN pub-:. 
lishes Anything that Moves, a maga-) 
zine with worldwide distribution ° 
that is produced by and for bisexu- : 


als and their family and friends. 
Rubenstein is still a vocal partici- 


A ; pant in the bisexual movement and: : 


: WaShonouredas Grand Marshall of 


ve the LBGT pride parade i in San Fran-:. 


: ‘cisco. in 1992. The Daily had the 
{à Opportunity to talk with her on July 


+183 1995 about. Where the: bisexual. 
| movement is now vand how far it has: 


come.’ Wed 
NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


Daily:Whatinspired you 
to come out in 1970,at 


 atime when there wasn’t 


much to identify with, 


: when there wasn’ta real 


community? And how did 
this lead to the forma- 
tion of the BiCenter? 


Maggi Rubenstein: The 
Stonewall riots against the 
police [in 1969, which raised 
the issue of discrimination 
against queer people] really 
made me realise that the is- 
sue of sexual rights was go- 
ing to have to be addressed 
at some point... I’ve started 
other organisations, and you 
know, why not do something 
for bisexuals? [So I asked 
myself] “how dol start doing 
that?” Well, | gotta put my 
ass on the line... [But] “What 
can I say? Where do |] say it? 
How do | say it? What do | 
talk about?”... So, I decided 
that the Center was the obvi- 
ous place to begin... | 
thought, “Gee we should all 
join together.” 

I didn’t think there would 
be such turf issues - “This is 
us [lesbians and gays] over 
here and that is you [bisexu- 
als] over there.” I have had 
some people actually say, 
“Well, why don’t 
you do yon own pa- 

rade?” ; “Why 
don’t vol Lo over 
there and/do your 
movement?” Well I 
said | don’ t believe | sa 
in séparate but |. 
equal, J think we alt 
neced?to support hey, 
each’ other: The fn 
more: We are to- [ly 
gether,” ‘the, More 
parallel we: are)’ 


aS 


You talk apo 
how you don’t 
like the idea of | 
separate but 
equal, so what do 
you think of the 
bicentric move- 
mentin Washington D.C. 
where they just fight for 
bisexual rights? 


[ feel that there are some peo- 
ple who need to just be with 
their own group in order to get 


\o/ 


a sense of power and impor- 
tance. Certainly that is hap- 
pening in the civil rights and 
the women’s rights move- 
ment... 

I know a lot of people need 
to get a power base, get a sense 
of their own pride and a sense 
of their own community and 
to speak from that. I support 
that, but] think in the bisexual 
movement thatis a rather nar- 
row view, because... it is im- 
portant to support all people’s 
rights. Ifanybody is oppressed, 
we are all oppressed and what- 
ever the struggle... 

[ think sometimes that it 
has been easier and more com- 
fortable, in a crazy kind of 
way, to hang out with the gay 
and lesbian community and 
push for our rights there, than 
to [fight for our rights] in the 
general community... There 
are a lot of bisexual people; 
but being bisexual is not just 
about getting it on: There are 
some bisexuals thatdon’t want 
to think about oracknowledge 
the sexual aspect of being bi- 
sexual. Some people get too 
political, but, well, “Let’s not 
talk about the sex part be- 
cause we don’t want people to 
think thatthe all bisexuals are 
obsessed with sex”. 

| have; been looking à at athe 





too. We’re not all just com- 
pletely and absolutely female 
or male. We all have female- 
ness and maleness in.us; emo- 
tionally, intellectually, and 
physically sometimes... As 
Marjorie Garber says in her 
book, Vice Versa, it is a new 
way of looking at human sexu- 
ality. It turns everything up- 
side down. 


About this idea of con- 
tinuums. Do you see it as 
areal scale? Do you think 
that we really can put a 
scale to sexuality? 




















don’t want 
to put a 
scale on 
sexuality; 

would. rather 
not use any la- 
bels at all. :Ifwe 
were not oppressed, | 
we wouldn't need to 
use any labels. There*\: 


wouldn’t need to have a WY 
gay rights movement or ¢ 
a women’s rights move- © 


ment or a bisexual move- 
ment, or any other rights 
movement if there wasn’t op- 
pression. If everybody ac- 
cepted everybody else as they 
are and celebrated their 
differences as well as their 
Similarities, there 
wouldn’t be a need for ps 
bels. 

My feeling is thats the 


1 more people understand 


that we all fit along [the 


/\q continuum] somewhere, 


the less people will con- 


cL Ne eg ete jtinte!. to” dichotomise,., 





i. Ay 


continuum of ender the con- 
tinuum of race, the continuum 
of sexuality. I think we all fit 
on those continuums some- 
where. In the transgender com- 
munity, I have become more 
sensitised to the fact that we 
are all along the gender scale 


e AK aN 


“Even among the bisexual: 
4 community, [people say] 
2 YOu guys are in the mid-: 
1 die.” No. We are... the 
Kinsey scale from 1 to 5S... 
Garber’s book, Vice 
Versa, quoted me as say- 
ing that 80 per cent of 
| the population could be 
| bisexual if we acknowl- 
cage our fantasies, our 
A eee oir interests, our 
crushes. ' normal curves 
hold true, then maybe 10 
per cent of the population 
is totally gay and lesbian and 
maybe 10 per cent is totally 
heterosexual and maybe eve- 
rybody else is potentially 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 








E STATUS QUO 








vith Maggi Rubenstein 






bisexual... 

I think a lot of it has to do 
with the monogamy bias we 
have in this country... All bi- 
sexuals are seen as non-mo- 
nogamous people, people that 
just getitonwith anything, 


that moves... The 
myths and the 


themselves... If people can 
see that we are all in this 
together, that we are all mul- 


tira-~ cial, we are all 
os multisexual, that 
es &\ we are all 


soon multigendered, 
that we are all 
along these 


stereotypes [continu- 
about bi- Los eave ee u m sg] 
sexu- sis sy RS some- 
) ne a we oe where, 
ue x then | 


abound. 
They certainly 
abounded in the 
'70s: All bisexual peo- 
ple can’t make commit- 
ments, they are fence sitters, 
they can’t make up their 
minds, they are sneaky liars. 
The monogamous bias [says 
that] non-monogamous peo- 
ple — and I am a non-mo- 
nogamous person — can’t 
make serious commit- 
ments. | have people in 
my life who I have known § 
for 20 years and we are 


î " 
still good friends and get BiA \: À 
it on and have a good D | A 
& time... PA DE) 
“When. people undér. 


stand: the: fact: that: most \ 
people have same-sex feel-\ à 


ings and other-sex feel- |: 
ings — whether or not | *% 


they talk about it or do 
anything about it — this 
Will help people break 
down their prejudice 
about bisexuality and 
about gay and lesbian 
people. | think that if peo- 
ple can see that piece of 


ity still 





THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL/ISSUE 


og. \ think 
that 


à) 


OPES \ 


as SL 





Aor eaks 
down 
prejudice, 


You were one of 

the first outspoken 
bisexuals to stand up 
for bi rights. What has 


»Kepteyou involved with 
qe movement for solong? 





| think some of the things that 
have kept me involved — not 
only in, the bisexual commu- 
nity but\in the women’s com- 
munity, and the lesbian/gay 
community — isto look ahead, 
to not give up, to not get dis- 
couraged}To not agonise, but 
organise, To not [resort to] 
violence‘and say it is all nOpes 


ay UNITY ¥ 


NA/ LS OUR 
BI À 
WORD 4 


Wt bok 1044 
. à 




























less what is the use. To just 
keep struggling and having a 
lot of fun. That’s the impor- 
tant thing: to have a good time 
while you are doing your poli- 
tics. You gotta really enjoy it. 
You're doing the work you love 
to do, and that’s what makes it 
work for you, and that is why 
people like me and others have 
hung in for all these years... 


Seeing that you have the 
unique perspective of 


having seen the bisexual 


movement grow from its 
birth to whatitisnow,§ 
can you tell us how it 
has changed? Are peo- 
à\ ple more receptive to 
Ne now? If so, to whatk 
CE 4 





Officially there is we 
much more recognition, 


ways, about our sexuality. Peo- | 


ple like us [bisexuals] are al- 
ways going to be viewed with 
Suspicion by someone, the 
Jesse Helmses of the world. 
The right wing wants to see 
bisexual people done away 
with in some fashion... In fact, 
we are even Seen as more aber- 
rant because they believe that 
we could make a choice and 
have not. But we have made a 
choice: We are bisexual. 
[wantto talkabout the word 
queer for a minute. | like the 
word queer, | like it because it 


but on a personal level Fi 


there is still some resist- & 
ance, Gay and lesbian l& 
people still have some in- | 

ternalised biphobia. 
Among bisexual people 
therearestill people who À 
are trying to figure out 
whatit all means. [A com- 
mon question is] “Can I 


have a relationship with [FA 


someone and be monoga- 
mous if I am bisexual?” Sure 
you can if that is what vou 
Want to do, and more. 


Do you think that bisexu- 
als are really visible yet 
in the world? 


More so in cosmopolitan ar- 
eas, but I still think 
that a lot of people 
haven’t gotten the 
message yet. A lotof 
| people don’t read 
very much. A lot of 
people have a belief 
system that is hard 
m to challenge, and 
this isacountry that 
1H promotes Christian- 
ity to the Nth de- 
gree... This isacoun- 
try that promotes 
complacency and 
discourages people 
for challenging so- 
Mass values. We 
are a nation of 
8 iene, in a lot of 








is all inclusive. The only thing 
that I don’tlike about the word 
queer is that some people who 
would otherwise call them- 
selves bisexual might call 
themselves queer as a way of 
aligning themselves with the 
gay and lesbian community 
instead of having to define 
who they are, I think it is im- 
portant [that] as long as bi- 
sexual is a word that people 
don't like, we have to speak 
out about it, say... “But I am 
not just queer, | am a bisexual 
queer,” 

We will always have to be 
spoken about; it will be forgot- 
ten about if it isn’t. I want 
people to read Marjorie 
Garber’s book and I want peo- 
ple to read Martin Weinberg’s 
book [Dual Attraction], even 
though it had some flaws... I 
want people to begin to talk to 
each other, questioning and 
challenging some of the val- 
ues that run society, false val- 
ues that white is best, that 
marriage is best, that mo- 
nogamy is best, that hetero- 


sexuality is best, and so forth. 
Challenge those values... 

It’s all about the existential 
angst that we all feel inside not 
knowing who we are. If we can 
come to terms with who we 
really are as bisexual people 
and not be afraid, then our 
lives will work a lot better for 
US... 

We are raised to distrust 
people who are different. That 
Starts in daycare centres and 
continues through grammar 
school and middle school and 
high school. Remember those 
few years in middle 
school? | think 
[that's] the toughest 
age of all for kids. | 
You hit puberty, your 
sexual feclings are all 
over the place, you 
may have some feel- 
ings for men, you 
may have some feel- 
ings for women, you 
may act on them, you 
may not. Confusing 
time. Remember also 
AT Chat alot of kids who 

eee) con't get support kill 
Sage) themselves, or live 
sees) lives that don’t work 
Ed for them, which tears 

M4 up families. 

Childhood is when 
kids need to get information 
about the goodness of sexual- 
ity. | think the more informed 
a child is, whether they are 
gay, lesbian, bisexual, 
transgender or straight, the 
more informed they get. The 
more permission they get, the 
better they will be able to make 
conscious choices, and the 
more assertive they are going 
to be in asking for what they 
want from a partner instead of 
just going along with what their 
partner wants, A lot of people 
don’t get that support and 
sometimes they die. 


As advice to future gen- 
erations of activists, what 
do you think is the best 
way to challenge the val- 
ues that are in place and 
the way society is set-up? 





Read, Write, Talk, Act. You can 
theorise about a lot of stuff, but 
it has to be taken into action. 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 





# A LOOK BEYOND 


TRANSSEXUALITY AND MY CONVERSATION 
WITH OLIVIA JENSEN 


was sitting in the Faculty 

Club a little past 7:00 pm 

Wailing for Olivia Jensen, a 
McGill Professor. Thinking 
Over the questions on 
transgender issues which I had 
prepared, | didn't notice the 
striking woman standing right 
in front of me. Very tall and 
stately, with an air of self- 
confidence, she had, arriving 
just before me, gone to put her 
things in the coat room. 

Introductions out of the 
way, we walked into the lounge 
and Olivia called up for two 
pints of beer. Then we sat down 
and began to talk. 

And so began one of the 
most fascinating = and 
entertaining Conversations | 
have ever had, 

Olivia, who has been 
teaching in the department of 
geophysics since 1973, has 
been known at MeGill both as 
A man and a woman. These 
days, after undergoing 
hormone therapy and sexual- 
reassignment surgery (SRS) 
In the early ‘90s, Olivia makes 
her Way in the feminine form. 
Prior to this, Olivia was married 
lor 13 years and has two 
Children, 13 and 16 vears old. 

| asked if the departments 
of Engineering and Geophysics 
had reacted awkwardly to the 
change, Olivia assured me that 
everyone had been relatively 
accepting, 

“My colleagues at McGill 
have been proper and good. 
[But] they haven't gone out of 
their way to 
accommodate 
me... [IS a very 
+ TM i {bh Uh x 
discrimination... 
It's never 
neglected, it is 
factored into 
Who lam. In a 
strange way, it’s 
okay, | want 
them to factor it 
ins) justi = not 
negatively,” she 
said. 

Most people, she said, once 
put in the situation of having 
to deal with a transsexual, 
simply take it in stride. 

“l expect to be treated well. 
| don’texpect to be humiliated, 
discounted, harassed... But it 
does happen at some level,” 
she said, adding that most 
instances have been temporary 
with people that she won't see 
again, 

“(Such instances] are part 
of the woodwork of life,” she 
noted. 


by Derek Fung 


| am a transsexual 
woman 

Transition is an essential part 
of adjusting to a new gender 


“L want [people] 
toreada 
transsexual 
woman that 
commands 
immediate 
respect. That's 
what | want, 
that Is the deal I 
try to make 
with the world. | 
don't want to be 
hidden.” 





role. The process involves 
hormone therapy and SRS, The 
Harry Benjamin International 
Gender Dysphoria Association 
has set strict guidelines for 
candidates who apply for the 
treatment, 

These include getting 
Written approval from a 
certified therapist after atleast 
three months of counseling 
and living full-time in the 


‘| think lesbians, gays, bisexuals, 


and transsexual people are the 

healthy variations of humanity. 

Only some moralists don't like it 
and that’s a small reason [for 


discrimination],” 





sought-after gender for atleast 
a year. The association also 
specifies that potential 
candidates cannot be married. 
Once you start transition, you 
can turn back, but after 
surgery itis next toimpossible. 

Like adolescence, transition 
isa time tocome to terms with 
a Whole new identity. The 
process should not be rushed. 

“The statement you make 
on transition is where you are 
going to live in the world,” 
Olivia explained. 

Many transsexuals want to 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


—— ns 


change their sex À 
and slip into the 
mainstream. They 
don’t want to be 
“read” (that is to 
have people Fr 
discover that they | 38 
have had sex 
reassignment), 

Olivia, who is 
very open about 
her transsexuality, 
doesn’t share this 
view. 2 

“Iwant [people] | 
to read ar © 
transsexual 
woman that 
commands]. 
immediate hos 
respect. That's 
what I want, thatis 
the deal I try to FA 
make with the Et 
world. Idon’twant #5 
to be hidden. That ss 
doesn't do Bigeee 
anything. That Es 
doesn’t make ag 
statement, notthat § 
Iwantmy life tobe ff 
astatementeither, | 
really,” she stated, | 
“My truth is this, It 
isn't that I ama 
female woman 
Who has finally been fixed. 
That's not the issue at all.” 

Related to this, is gender 
etiquette. One inevitable 
question is what terms to use 
when addressing transsexuals 
—heorshe, Mr. or Ms., manor 
woman? 

For Olivia, 
it’s important 
to respect the 
Dems Ones 
decisions and 
refer to their 
Diréers ent 
gieoned ie rz. 
Usually 
though, she 
said this hasn’t 
been a 
problem. 

“The world 
is SO good, so 
positive, that even if [people 
read me], they know how | 
want tobe read, That's gender 
etiquette,” she said. 


Who's normal? 
These days, everyone seems 
to be trying to explain 
transsexuality and 
homosexuality. Some scientists 
look for genes and others 
compare the size of the 
hypothalamus, 

But it is important not be 
caught up with the ‘norm’. 
Normal isn’t necessarily 


i eaten ae ee 


ieee aoe 
pone ee eee 


better.“normal is only a 
statistical measure. It is only 
what most people are doing. It 
isn’t good or bad.” 

As Olivia observed, 

Different sexualities —homo/ 
bi/transsexuality — arose 
naturally. They have evolved as 
part of human experience — but 
haven't always had an outlet for 
expression in society. 

“[But lately] the world has 
opened the door wider for us... I 
think lesbians, gays, bisexuals, 
and transsexual people are the 
healthy variations of humanity. 
Only some moralists don’t like it 
and that’s a small reason [for 
discrimination],” said Olivia. 

She did acknowledge, 


“Normal is only a 


statistical measure. It 
is only what most 
people are doing. It 
isn’t good or bad.” 





me) 
(a) 


“aia 


+ «0 
CON 
Pm el) 


dads....would say that it is 
wonderful [to havea transsexual 
child]. They would jump to 
abortion and that is 
disappointing.” 

But no one has the right to 
take away possibilities for a 
person's future, simply 
because they are different. It 
may justbe that transsexuality, 
as well as homo/bisexuality, is 
seen as a disease or disorder 
by many because they lack 
experience with it and are 
scared of it. 

=ToËfindÆ=acure for 
transsexuality means thatitis 
bad or a disease. It 
[undermines] the evolution of 
one’s transsexuality. It would 
be a tragedy to me 
to remove that 
possibility. Itdenies 
a future. That is 
immoral.” 

Despite the lack 
of awareness, Olivia 
remains positive 
and proud of her 
transsexuality, “For 
along time, I wished 





however, that many people still 
dismiss transsexuality as 
aberrent, She commented that if 
à pre-natal screen for 
transsexuality were ever 
developed, “Not many momsand 


| that] had been born 
a female, It’s not the 
case any more. It’s not the way 
I would have liked my past to 
have been. | like my past to be 
exactly as it was because that 
brings me here... exactly where 
I should be.” 


12 THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 





Olivia Jensen 





PE ont Rass er re Pi ES 


sas" 


aa free 








HELPING THE BODY? 
FIT THE MIND 


THE SEX REASSIGNMENT PROCESS 


by Kevin Siu 





n individual who 

wishes to undergo sex 

reassignment must 
follow the guidelines dictated 
by the Benjamin Standards. 
Initially approved in 1979 at 
the Sixth Gender Dysphoria 
Symposium, the Benjamin 
Standards were intended as a 
“statement of the standard of 
care to be offered to dysphoric 
patients.” The standards have 
been widely accepted. 

First, the applicant must 
obtain the written approval of 
a certified therapist after no 
less than three months of 
consultation. During the year 
before the actual sex 
reassignment surgery (SRS), 
the individual must undergo 
Real Life Training, in which 
he/she presents himself/ 
herself full-time in the other 
gender role. The presentation 
extends itself to previously 
unconscious activities such as 
bathroom usage and the choice 
of title (i.e. Mr., Ms., Mrs., Miss). 

During this preparation 
period, the individual will also 
likely undergo hormone 
therapy to prepare the body 
for the SRS. 


Male to female, female to 
male 

During the estrogen therapy, 
the male-to-female (M2F) 
candidate will immediately 
experience faster hair and nail 
growth, the growth of softer 
and thicker hair, and 
moodiness as his body adjusts 
to the female hormones. 

The genetic male will 
gradually lose muscle mass 
and develop more fat tissue in 
the breast and hip areas. The 
penis will lose its ability to 
function and the testicles will 
Shrink. The individual’s sex 
drive will also decrease 
dramatically. Though the 
male’s bone structure and 
voice will not be altered, 
physically, the applicant will 
appear almost completely 
female after one or two years. 

For female-to-male (F2M) 
candidates, androgen therapy 
(depo-testosterone is 
commonly used) will 
immediately induce muscle 
growth, particularly in the 
chest area. The genetic female 
will also experience facial and 
body hair growth 
accompanied by outbreaks of 


the F2M candidate 


-acne. Like M2F candidates 


undergoing hormone therapy, 
will 
experience mood swings 
during the initial adjustment 
period. 

After a year of hormone 


therapy, the candidate’s voice 


will have deepened. The 
clitoris will lengthen by about 
two inches, and there will be 
beard growth and male pattern 
baldness. The F2M candidate 
will probably have stopped 
menstruating. Apart from the 
primary sex organ (vagina) 
and secondary sex organs 
(breasts), the individual will 
appear almost completely 
male. 

Although hormone therapy 
can be reversed, some effects 
are permanent. Most M2F 
candidates are permanently 
infertile after six months of 
taking estrogen. For F2M 
candidates taking androgen, 
the facial hair growth and 
deepening of the voice are 
irreversible. Breast growth is 
also permanent. Most other 
body changes that occur 
during hormone therapy will 
disappear eventually if 
therapy is discontinued, 


Making the move to 
surgery 
The financial costs of SRS being 
so high (between $6 000 and 
$50 000), many 
transgendered lack the means 
to complete the sex 
reassignment process. Some 
transgendered also find 
themselves psychologically 
unprepared to face the 
irreversibility of the surgery. 
For an M2F candidate, SRS 
involves four main steps. First, 
the testicles are removed. The 
penis is then inverted to create 
an opening resembling a 
vagina. The remaining scrotum 
is used to line the opening, 
creating a labia. Finally, a 
portion of the penile tissue is 
restructured to form the 
clitoris. The nerve endings 
from the penis are left intact 
so that the transsexual is 
capable of having orgasms. 
For a F2M candidate, the 
procedure is more complex, 
requiring surgery on both the 
primary and secondary sex 
Organs, First, the individual 
must undergo a double 
mastectomy. Both breasts are 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 


removed, but the nipples are 
retained and repositioned. 
This procedure can be 
performed during the 
preparation period. After at 
least a year, the candidate can 
undergo the hysterectomy, in 
which the uterus, ovaries and 
fallopian tubes are removed, 

New procedures forcreating 
a penis are being developed, 


but phalloplasty and 
metoidioplasty are currently 
the most common. 


Metoidioplasty involves using 
the enlarged clitoris as the 
basis for the penis. It is a less 
complex and less expensive 
procedure than phalloplasty. 
However, because the resulting 
penis is only about two inches 
long, metoidioplasty is not 
feasible for penile penetration. 

The second option ‘is 
phalloplasty. After a period ot 
electrolysis on the abdomen; 
the skin.the.area is used ta 
form a-tube of skin. Because 
the clitoris is positioned 
underneath the resulting 
penis, sexual stimulation is still 
possible but not easy. 

A more extensive form of 
phalloplasty involves the 
transplant of a forearm nerve 
into the skin tube. Running 
into the nerves of the clitoris, 
the transplanted nerve allows 
a wide range of sensation, To 
erect the constructed penis 
after phalloplasty, there are a 
number of pumps and inserts 
that vary in effectiveness. 


Gender definition 

After SRS, the transsexual must 
continue hormone treatment 
for the rest of his/her life. 
Although certain effects of 
hormones are permanent, if a 


transsexual stops therapy, his/ 
her features will largely return 
to their original state. Some 
transsexuals, in particular M2F 
transsexuals, attend finishing 
schools after surgery to 
improve their adoption of the 
chosen gender role, 

The sex reassignment 
procedure — the preparation, 
surgery, and post-operation 
considerations — raises many 
questions. The Benjamin 
Standards were developed 
partially in response to the 
high correlation between 
suicide and sex reassignment 
during the period when SRS 
Was first introduced. 

However, there are 
objections in the transgender 
community to the stringent 
guidelines imposed by the 
Benjamin Standards. 
Arguments are increasingly 
being made over the right of 
transsexuals to determine for 
themselves when they are 
ready for surgery. 

The debate also questions 
whether the medical 
establishment should dictate 
the behaviour and lifestyle of 
sex reassignment candidates 
during the preparation period. 
Some feel that being required 
to act a certain way (i.¢. take 
on a dictated gender role) 
reinforces socially defined 
distinctions between males 
and females that may not be 
valid toa particular individual. 

As surgery edges closer to 
being able to fully reconstruct 
the body, the legal and health 
care implications also become 
more salient. When is an 
individual considered legally 
and medically one sex or the 
other? 


INTERNATIONAL 


Queer 





ew Zealand gets first 
transsexual mayor 

Georgina Beyer was elected 
as the first transsexualk 

ayor of the Wiararapa 


ownship in New Zealand. 


cuts 


There have been other 
examples of transsexual 
politicians. One of Canada’s 
own transsexual politicians 
was forced to resign after 


threats of violence. 


Asking whether gender 
distinction is important in the 
first place emphasises the fact 
that transgender issues go 
beyond just the sex 
reassignment procedure. As 
social perceptions of gender 
roles continue to shift, the 
process of the mind trying to 
understand the body becomes 
a process of helping the body 
fit the mind. 


Sources for this article 
include: The New Yorker, July 
A) Uy 1994, the 
ali. transgendered newsgroup 
and the most recent draft of 
the Benjamin Standards. 





nade 
the 


rans ge 
rganisations in 
ontréal area: 


FACT-Quebee 

Fact,c/o Mrs. Patricia Fishes 

Box 293, Cote-des-Neiges 
ost Office 

5858 Cote-des-Neiges Blvd. 

Montréal 13S 256 

Fact-Québec is a support 
:roup for transsexuals, their 
Jartners, relatives, friends and 
yrofessionals in the field. Fact- 
Juébec can also provide 
speakers to the public. 


Club Met 

4113 Dorion St. 

Montreal H2K 3B8 

528-8874 

Club Met is a non-sexual 
support eroup for 
ransgendered and their 
Jartners. Club Met also 
Jublishes its own news 
nagazine. 





Putting the heat on Costa 
Rica 

The Magnus Hirschfeld| 
Center for Human Rights has 
filed acomplaint with the Inter- 
American Commission on 
Human Rights against Costa 
Rican police and media 
harrassing queer people, 

The commission has a 
mandate to enforce the 
American Convention on 
Human Rights, an agreement 
between countries in South 
and North America. making 
its decisions have the force 
of law, 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 





8 Hate legislation visits 


by Meredith Cohen 


ou are walking down 

the street clad in fire 
engine red bell-bot- 

toms. Shocking is the 

word. Fiendish. Apparently 
someone perceives your vin- 
lage style as a bit too subver- 
sive and offensive for this black 
and white world. This some- 
one, in a gallant act, rallies up 
bunches of friends to protect 
this world and its posterity 
from this most garish display. 
Organisations form (ooh), 
platforms form (ahh), and with 
incredulous heads whirling, 
agendas form (gasp). Sud- 
denly, out vapid hatred and 
disgust, anamendmentis born. 
Itlegislates this hatred by con- 
structing legal barriers to all 
and any members of 
bellbottom donning clan. If 
you partake in this heinous 
crime, then you will have no 


Se A 


ability to seek legal repercus- 
sion if you are discriminated 
against or even physically 
harmed. The new legislation 
prevents you from doing so. 

Surely Colorado's Amend- 
ment 2 is much different; but 
itis also quite similar. Replace 
queer human with human in 
bellbottoms, and the similari- 
ties will be striking, garish 
even. lam not certain which is 
more ludicrous, 


A powerful signal 

Soon alter its birth, Amend- 
ment 2, the brainchild of the 
organisation Colorado for 
Family Values, went straight 
to the Colorado court system 
Where it was repealed as un- 
constitutional based on its 
breach of the First Amend- 
ment. Just as quickly, however 
itwas appealed and sent to the 
Supreme Court where it was 
heard on October 10. 


NovemBer 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


the 





Vigils, rallies, 
press conferences 
and teach-ins 
dominated the 
Colorado. land- 
scape; and that of 
many otherstates, 
the day before the 
Supreme Court 
Hearing, 

The Amend- 
ment, reproduced 
above, was.a first 
of many attempts 
by the radical 
right to besiege 
local and state 
governments. It 
has recently been 
followed by simi- 
lar initiatives in 
Maine, and will be 
attempted in 
Idaho and Oregon 
in 1996. 

Should the Su- 
preme Court re- 
peal the Colorado 
court decision, 
any member of 
the queer community — les- 
bian, gay, or bisexual — resid- 
ing in the state of Colorado 
Will be stripped of any ability 
to seek legal redress for dis- 
crimination or anti-gay vio- 
lence. 

This would set a precedent 
of singling out one specific 
group and drastically limiting 
their legal and political power. 
Aruling such as this would not 
only be detrimental to the 
queer community, but to the 
civil rights movement in gen- 
eral, 

According to Melinda Paras, 
executive director of the Na- 
tional Gay and Lesbian Task 





AM ENDMENT 9 


Neither the State of Colt 
through any branches or departments, 
nor any of its agencies, political sub- 
divisions, municipalities or school 
districts, shall enact, adopt, or en- 
force any statute, regulation, ordi- 
nance or policy whereby homosexual, 
lesbian, or bisexual orientation, con- 
duct, practices or relationships shall 
constitute or otherwise be the basis of 
or entitle any person or class of per- 
sons to have or claim any minority 
status, quota preferences, protected 
status, or claim discrimination. 





Force, “Amendment 2 doesn’t 
just impact Colorado, As al- 
ways a Supreme Court hear- 
ing sends a powerful signal. In 
this case the court can stand 
in defense of equal participa- 
tion and fair play for all, or it 
can codify discrimination 


against a targeted group. If 


the Supreme Court overturns 
the repeal, it will be hailed by 
the radical right as justifica- 
tion for ongoing efforts in 
other states.” 


“Special rights” unde- 
fined 


Do all Americans have the 


THE 


samerighttobe 
a part the na- 
tion’s democ- 
racy? Thisisthe 
question which 
the Supreme 
Court will an- 
swer, when it 
hands down its 
decision some- 
time between 
January and 
June, 

Those who 
support 
Amendment 2 
contend that 
through gay 
rights legisla- 
tion, the queer 


seeking “spe- 
cial rights”. But 
when asked to 
specify the 
“special rights” 
being sought, 
Gale Norton, at- 
torney-general 
of Colorado re- 
plied, “We don't really know 
exactly.” 

She did, however, offer the 
example of work quotas which 
would force anti-gay groups 
into hiring queer individuals. 
This could be construed as the 


accusation of “special rights”. 


The lack of an adequate 
definition for what the “spe- 
cial rights” in question are, 
formed an important part of 
the defense as it violated the 
“rational basis” of the amend- 
ment. The defense highlighted 
the fact that dislike is not a 
rational basis for discrimina- 
tory treatment in the face of 
the law. 


Reuicious Alen 


ce SAILS ()N 


community is. 


the US Supreme Court 


Suzanne _B. Goldberg, staff 
attorney at Lambda Legal 
Defense and Education Fund, 
which along with the Ameri- 
can Civil Liberties Union 
worked to defend the Colo- 
rado Supreme Court injunc- 
tion of Amendment 2, said 
“Amendment 2 is an outra- 
geous violation of the Consti- 
tution, and sets out to erect 
special barriers for the queer 
community.” 

It is not always accurate to 
predict the outcome of a hear- 
ing based on its oral argu- 
ments. But court observer 
Kevin Sherrill says he expects 
the decision to support the 
original injunction ruled by 
the Colorado Supreme court. 

A ruling in favour of the 
injunction would be a good 
one for the civil rights move- 
ment in the US. In the ’60s, 
similar legislation was used to 





limit the representation of Af- 
rican-Americans. 

A ruling against the amend- 
ment would also be positive 
for the Queer Community by 
sending a signal to the radical 
right that their legal attempts 
are unconstitutional. 

It will also provide legal 
precedent for the “Don’t ques- 
tion, Don’t tell” policy of the 
military that is expected to be 
heard by the Supreme Court 
next year. 

For those objecting to 
Amendment 2, things look 
hopeful. But the forces pro- 
posing such legislation are just 
as confident. In his resigna- 
tion statement, the former di- 
rector and founder of Colo- 
rado for Family Values stated 
“The passion of protecting our 
children, our lives and, our 
future from homosexual ag- 
gression burns deeply within 
me.” It could be a close battle. 


z \ia/ THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 





: SSeS 1 = 








Whydo we need a gaygene? 


Taking a closer look at the nature vs. nurture debate 


S scientists search for 
a biological 
explanation for 
homosexuality, many express 
concern about the necessity 
of locating a “gay gene” — 


and the possible 
consequences arising 
therefrom, 


As recently as 1974, 
homosexuality was listed by 
the American Psychiatric 
Association as a mental 
disorder. Even today, more 
thanafewwould characterize 
it as ‘deviant’ behaviour at 
best, willful evil at worst. 

As such, the possibility of 
discovering biological proof 
that homosexuality is a 
naturally occurring trait has 
been welcomed by some 
members of the LBGT 
community, 

However, some object to 
the direction of recent 
Studies, saying they don’t 
need “justification” for being 
pay, 

Investigative research on 
the topic has encompassed 
everything from DNA linkage 
to tracing fingertip ridges. 

Dr. Simon LeVay, a 
neuroanatomist at the Salk 
Institute in La 
California, has been noted 


for his studies comparing.” 


brain size in deceased AIDS 
Victims. 


LeVay claimed to have 


discovered innate biological 
differences when he found 
notable discrepancies in the 
sizes of the hypothalomi of 
homosexual and 
heterosexual men. 

Significant evidence has 
shown, however, that the 
experience of an individual 
can affect and alter brain 
development. As such, many 
question his assertion that 
the difference in brain 
Structure is a cause, rather 
than an effect, of 
homosexuality. 

Above all, the biggest 
shortfall of LeVay’s study was 
the fact that all the subjects 
were dead, making a clear 
assertion of their sexuality 
impossible, 


And the 
shows... 
Research looking into the 
possible genetic aspect of 
homosexuality has yielded 
more plausible results. 

In 1991, researchers 
Michael Bailey and Richard 
Pillard discovered the high 
probability (52 per cent) of 


research 


Jolla, . 


by Mera Thompson 





one identical twin being 
homosexual if the other one 
Was. 

They also uncovered 
similar findings that were 
lower, but still significant, for 
non-identical twins, non-twin 
siblings and adopted 
brothers (22, 9, and 11 
percent, respectively). 

But several questions were 
raised by their findings. 

Firstly, if homosexuality 


were exclusively. linked to 


genetic make-up then 
identical twins — who share 
allofthe same genes — would 
both be homosexual or 
heterosexual all of the time. 
secondly, the fact that 
adopted brothers were more 
likely to both be gay than 
non-twin siblings, supports 
the theory that environment 
and upbringing may have 
more to do with sexual 
arientation than genetics. 
Dr. Dean Hamer and 
colleagues from the American 
National Institute of Health 
performed DNA analysis on 


gay brothers. They found a * 


significant linkage betiveen 
homosexual orientation and 
markers in a region of the X 
Chromosome, known asXq28, 
wasdetected in 82.5per cent 


“of ‘examined homosexual! 


brothers. 

Discarding the slight 
probability that such co- 
inheritance happened by 
Chance alone (approximately 
l per cent), the report 
concluded that “it appears 
that Xq28 contains a gene 
that contributes to 
homosexual orientation in 
males.” 

Dr. Hamer himself does not 
see his study as tantamount 
to the discovery of what 
“causes” homosexuality. 

“Sexual orientation is too 
complex to be determined by 
a single gene. The main value 
of this work is that it opens a 
window into understanding 
how genes, the brain and the 
environmentinteract to mold 
human behaviour,” Hamer 
explained. | 

Yet to be determined, is 
exactly howa gene may effect 
sexual orientation: directly, 
by shaping specific parts of 
the brain, or indirectly, 
affecting temperament that 
predisposes a boy towards 
homosexuality. 


Equal rights or excuses? 
Reactions to this trend of 
scientific research have been 


gay ‘gene. 


mixed, both in and outside of 
the queer community. 

Robert Bray, head of public 
information for the National 
Gay and Lesbian Task Force, 
Was encouraged by these 
studies. “It points out that 
gay people are made this way 
by nature. It strikes at the 
heart of people who oppose 
gay rights and who think we 
don’t deserve our rights 
because we're choosing to be 
the way we are.” 

Gregory iT’ King, 
spokesman for the Human 
Rights Campaign, Fund in 
Washington, D.C., concurs. 
“Fundamentally, it [genetic 
research] increases our 
understanding of the origins 
of sexual orientation, and at 
the same time we believe it 
will help) increase-public 
support for lesbian and gay 
rights.” | 

‘Others, like David 
D'Andrea, anactive member 


of Lesbian, Bisexual, Gay and ” 
Transgender Students of 
McGill (LBGTM), fault the” 
research movementfor being 


a defensive maneuveron the 


_ partof the queer community. 
~ssUsing the studies to prove 


that homosexuals are normal 
functioning hümans, there is 


—an almost apologetic tone to 


their findings,” he said; 


He said’ the general: 


population: should just learn 
to “live with. it [the reality 
that homosexuals exist],” 

7 D'Andrea dismissed those 
who, believe that locating a 
would erase 
prejudice against 
homosexuals. “Using that 


argument, there would be no». 


discrimination against blacks 
and other. ethnic groups or 
people with diseases,” he said. 

“I find it worrisome that 
this seems to be feeding into 
a societal trend, with people 


using [the research] to justify 


their own prkjudices, ” he 
added. 


“If that’s the way we're 
born...” | 

Many people worry that the 
genetic research will be 
interpreted as justification, 
Or an excuse, for being 
homosexual. 

Darrell Yates Rist, in à 
recent New York Times 
article, stated that he: had 
once used the “born that way” 
defense as an olive branch 
for his parents, who “wanted 
to exonerate themselves for 
creating a home that might 


be thought by some to have 
contributed to perversion,” 

There is still a lot of 
ambivalence about research 
trends which may provide a 
genetic “excuse” for 
homosexuality. Some gay 
rights leaders have 
denounced studies such as 
Dr. Hamer’s as “yet another 
attemptaatos Mara ven a 
reductionist and implacable 
line between homosexuality 
and heterosexuality.” 

John Fisher, executive 
director of Equality for Gays 
and Lesbians Everywhere 
(EGALE), went as far as’to 
state that such research is 
“irrelevant to any purposes 
[his] organization has.” 

But scientists such as 
LeVay, who himself is gay, 
claim to/have ventured into 
biological and genetic 
research in order to make 
society more accepting of 
homosexuality. 

“If it’s shown that that’s 


~the way we're born, it would 


undercut-the idea that we're 
just misbehaving,”. LeVay 
said. 

Fisher, ~ however, 
questioned what:effect such 


—-résearch Would have on those 


who strongly _ resist 


acknowledging homosexuals. 
as equal human beings. “I * 
shave limited confidence that 


~itwill:change anyone’s ideas 


if they:-are- steadfastly 
opposed to homosexuality.” 

Still, some continue to 
believe that the research will 
help the gay and lesbian 
community, if only in their 
legal maneuverings within 
the justice system. 

In a 1993 press release 
from the National 
Organization of Gay and 
Lesbian Scientists and 
Technical . Professionals 
(NOGLSTP), they reiterated 
theirhopes thatinthe debate 


over same-sex marriages, for 
example, discrimination} 


based on a genetically 
immutable ‘trait would be 
ruled a civil rights violation 
on a minority group. 


In search of a “cure”? 

Rist, who is also co-founder 
of the Gay and Lesbian 
Alliance Against Defamation, 
remains uninterested insuch 
studies. “Intellectually, what 
do we gain by finding out 
there’s a gay gene? Nothing 
except an alttemptto identify 
those people who have it and 
then open them up to all 


DAILY GRAPHIC BY MAX FRANCISCO 


sorts of experimentation to 
change them.” 

D'Andrea agreed. “The 
scary thingis not the research 
--it’show it’s being used and 
interpreted,” he said, 

Indeed, anxieties 
regarding the ethical 
questions arising from the 
location of a gay gene have 
been the dominant concern 
during the course of the 
research. 

The prospects of screening 
fetuses for genetic traits, and 
the possibility that marriage 
or childbearing might be 
restricted to “genetically 
desirable” people have 


alarmed the LBGT 
communily. 
AclivistS stress the 


importance of avoiding 
potential geneticenginecring 
and the science ofattempting 
ta “fix” homosexuality, 
perhaps through gene 
therapy or similar methods. 

One all gay activist with 
the Traditional Values 
Coalition was somewhat 
encouraged by thesuggestion 
that homosexuality may be 
biologically based, believing 
that medicine and science 
should now seek to 
genctically alter lesbian, gay, 


and bisexual people. 


Sois homosexuality caused 
by a specific gene? Or does it 
stem from upbringing, 
environment and individual 
personality? Perhaps a 
combination of all of these 
points? The consensus seems 
to be that it’s up to us all to 
decide for-ourselves. 

But perhaps.itcan best be 
summed up by John Fisher’s 
response when asked what 
he thought causes 
homosexuality. “I can’t 


explain itand | don’t feel that 
I need to.” 





THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE ( 15 ) NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


& 





8 THE QUESTION OF EQUALITY? 


By Meredith Cohen 


‘ omosexuality can 
happen to you. It can 
happen to anyone. 

What will you do if your 

parents find out? And they 

Will find out because you will 

get caught. If someone else 

does not catch you, then you 

Will be caught by your own 

mind.” 

Imagine that the year is 
1966. You and your peers are 
assembled in a school 
auditorium and a man stands 
before you, He is not a 
preacher, but he is preaching 
and this is what you are 
hearing. If you were an 
American youth in 1966, it 
could have happened to you. 

Imagine that you are queer 
in 1995 and some Reverend 
tclls you that reparative 
therapy could help rectify your 
gender identity problem. After 
all, that’s what homosexuality 
is—a gender identity problem 

and therapy has helped 
thousands geton the “straight” 
and narrow path. It could 
happen to vou. I may have. It 
happened to Lyn Duffin in 

LOO lima Wi Ole tte liSae was 

institutionalised by her mother 

after she told her that she was 


ore te 


nme SOR eR ey 





a lesbian. Lyn ran away. 

But her story is told, along 
With many others, Amongst 
Stories mclipsmMof#iriots: 
interviews, anti-queer 
propaganda and court trials, 
Hollow Liberty and Generation 
(2 , the first two productions 
in, The Question of Equality, a 
series of hour-long 
documentaries, weave an 
intricate tapestry of history. 
Together and separately, they 
present a collage of modern 
queer Culture and history. 

Through examination of the 
ship USS Norton Controversy 
and the notorious Hardwick 
case, Hollow Liberty implies 
that itis a series of events that 
were collectively part of an 
upward climb, 

The chronology begins in 
1980, the year that women 
were first allowed to serve in 
active duty in the navy. Norton 
was one of the first integrated 
ships. What ensued was awitch 
hunt of sorts, Of the 68 women 
crew members, 40 were 
removed for questioning and 
subjected to psychological 
testing. 24 women were 
eventually “honourably” 
discharged. No hard evidence 
Was ever documented to prove 
their performance was 
inadequate. In many ways the 


nine 
4 . 
Titre 





FAN HE phréid sait US 
mari bred Wed i seri rit ek. 


Generation Q 


INTERNATIONAL 


Queer cuts 





Zimbabwe goes 


another step too far 


Zimbabwe MP Acneas 
Chigwedere said that “[Gay 
people are] like tuberculosis 
patients, they should be 
hibernated [sic] in anisolation 
hospital until they are treated.” 


This statement was made in 
support of a motion made by 
President Robert Mugabe's 
anti-gay Campaign. 

Mugabe has been attacking 
queer people since August 1, 
when the Gay and Lesbians of 
Zimbabwe were banned from 
a state funded book fair. 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


Hollow Liberty and Generation Qat 


Image & Nation festival 


incident served as the 
harbinger to the current plea, 
still pending, for the rights of 
gays and lesbians to serve in 
the military. 

The 1980 outrage was 
closely followed by another in 
1982, when Georgian resident 
Michael Hardwick was arrested 
for sodomy after a policeman 
barged into his bedroom and, 
as they say, caught him in the 
act. What sounds more like a 
farce actually did occur. In a 
crowd-pleasing moment 
(granted the audience was a 
bit biased, and perhaps the 
reaction would have been 
different had we been 
members of the moral 
majority), then-Attorney 
General of Georgia Bowers 
says, in a thick Georgian 
accent, “I believe the ‘sodomy 
rules’ serve the morality of the 
people.” 

The accompanying vintage 
anti-homosexual propaganda 
from the ‘50s and ‘60s is even 
more amusing (“he was a 
healthy and athletic boy, he 
played football and he wanted 
to grow up to be areal man.”), 
Also featured is a short army 
propaganda film overflowing 
with homo-erotic 
undercurrents. The irony is 
cleverly placed. 

Hollow Liberty is not a joke, 
however, and poignant scenes 
of police brutality are 


interspersed with a clip of 


Bowers stating with all the glee 
that hisaccentcan muster that 
gays are no less second class 
citizens than individuals who 
commit rape or incest. 
Juxtaposed is footage of 
President Clinton, shown in a 
campaign speech saying that 
he would be lifting the military 
ban, and then shown in his 
speech during the first months 
of his presidency saying that 


Tokyo has its second 


pride parade 


2 200 marched in the 
second gay-pride parade in 
Tokyo, Japan. The march 
wound through the streets of 
the Shibuya neighborhood. 
Parade coordinator Kayoko 
Shirakawa said it was 
important for the parade to 
“be political, not just about 
having fun,” 

The day after the parade, 









NOLL : 





the ban would remain in place. 

Generation Q recounts a 
group of Massachusetts 
teenagers’ efforts to pass a bill 
protecting queer students 
against discrimination in 
schools. This video centers 
around interviews with the 
teenagers and with another 
group of queer youth that 
attend the Eagle Center, a 
school in Los Angeles. 

The school was founded by 
Jerry Batty to provide a safe 
place of education for lesbian 
and gay students who would 
have otherwise dropped out 
of school due to discrimination 
and harassment by their 
former peers. Ina particularly 
funny scene, a lesbian couple 
at the school is hosting a radio 
show. A Reverend Sheldon calls 
and comments that all queer 
culture centers around sex. 
One of the women answers, 


toto 


the prime minister’s office 
released the results of a poll 
saying that an overwhelming 
majority of Japanese citizens 
disapproved of anti-gay 
discrimination and 
discrimination against HIV- 
positive people. 


In the streets of 


Verona... 


5 000 queers marched 
through the streets of Verona 










With great aplomb, “I’m 
here with my girlfriend 
tonight to do this show, 
and I’m speaking with 
you, and I’m not 
fornicating as well.” 

From fornicating in 
| the bedroom to not 
/ fornicating at a radio 

station, Hollow Liberty 

and Generation Q 

create a provocative 
synthesis. While the first video 
leaves the viewer beguiled by 
the lunacy of rampant 
injustice, the second video 
offers a more optimistic 
picture of the strength of 
progressive youth, 

In Hollow Liberty, U.S. 
Congressman of Massachusetts 
Barney Frankstates “The queer 
community is doubly plagued 
with legal discrimination and 
cultural pulverisation. This 
occurs to such an extent that 
‘coming out’ is a political act; 
in fact anything we do that is 
culturally expressive is 
considered a political act.” 

If thisis true, and! do believe 
it is, then the achievement of 
these films is two-fold as well. 
They recuperate some of what 
is lost and buried of our history 
and accomplishments, and 
bring us together to viewthem, 
In your face, Bowers. 


wht des 
: ‘ ; t 





Mi ir SRE 
Michael Hardwick, from Hollow Liberty 


in protest of the Catholic 
dominated City.Council's 
resolution that calls 
homosexuality a “depraved 
behavior”. The march was 
organised by the Arcigay- 
Arcilesbica and the Verona Gay 
and Lesbian Movement. The 
City Council’s resolution was 
made in response to the 
European Parliament’s 
resolution urging all European 
Union member nations to grant 
queers equality. 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE 








=. ln. un € mt =- 


à _— 


ES ee CPU msn = 





Father, brother, teacher, friend ée 


anonymous 


efore this past July, I believed myself to 

be an open-minded straight girl with a 

“normal” straight life. I was — and still 
am — a social person with lots of good friends, 
two of whom! can relate to on all levels and call 
my best friends. I love being involved in soci- 
ety, and this past summer — quite randomly, 
in fact — I decided to fight any and all 
homophobia I came into contact with; 

Although I lived in what I knew was a 
relatively sheltered, straight world, [had some 
gay acquaintances and realised that 
homophobic behaviour was still accepted and 
even encouraged by too many people. I de- 
cided to expose myself to gay literature and 
film and promised to “get to know as many gay 
people as possible so I could better under- 
stand their culture.” 

Before I make it sound like lam condemning 
myself for my own naiveté, allow me to assure 
you that I have no problem with what my 
attitude was this summer. On the contrary, | 
believe that it was my interest in sexuality, gay 
culture and gay rights that encouraged one of 
my closest friends, Bill, to come out to me one 
day in July. 

Nothing could have made me feel more 
honoured and touched than his trust in me 
and I was genuinely happy that he came out. 
The experience which has so greatly influ- 
enced me and shaped my attitudes however, is 
not this one, but an incident that occurred the 





by Jen Mooney 


ost of the coming-out stories I have 

heard are about a queer rejected by 

her/his family and friends, The indi- 
vidual is left alone to deal with the anxiety, 
depression and pain of not being the status- 
quo “heterosexual.” 

While this is the sad truth for many 
people, I was fortunate that this is not my 
story. For me, coming out was one of the 
most self-affirming, beautiful and liberat- 
ing experiences of my life. | 

Like many queers, I assumed I was straight 
for the majority of my life, though growing up 
within a liberal family and among liberal 
peers, | had never had a problem with homo- 
sexuality, 

Bisexuality, however, was another story. 
| remember being 14 and arguing with my 
father about whether or not bisexuality was 
“real.” He, like many straight and gay peo- 
ple, felt that you had to be one or the other; 

I argued fiercely against this, without ever 
questioning why I felt so passionately. about 
bisexuality. 


From theory:to,reality | 
In Montreal — which was relatively accepting, 


compared to therepressed, conservative town: 


in which I spent most.of my. life — ]'began to 


explore what it would be like to kiss another 


woman. te BARTS RE Bo 
I eventually got up the courage to.do-so; 


and I started accepting that I could find other. 


women sexually attractive. 


Harbouring jan ‘unrequited: crush on’ a. 


woman in one of my classes,,] looked deep 


within to find out why my feelings for this: 


woman were “different”: from: those:] had 


following day. 

One of the two best friends I mentioned 
earlier is a guy I'll call Dan, who I had been in 
love with for.well.over a year. I do not use the 
term best friend lightly, and honestly felt, and 
still feel, that Dan is my perfect match. 

We have been best friends for more than 
three years and havea relationship made up of 
intense conversations and ‘concern for each 
other. Although I could not understand why 
we were not going out, I knew without a doubt 
that there was no one who was nearly as close 
to him as I was. 

Having said all that, there was one thing! did 
not know about Dan until July, less than four 
months ago today. On a beautiful summer 
night in Toronto's College Park, in a conversa- 
tion charged with emotions and filled with 
tears, Dan told me he was gay. I suddenly 
found myself caught in a situation in which I 
would never have wished to find myself, but 
Which has shaped my attitudes more than any 
other experience in my life. 

Nothing hurts more than not being able to 
have the person you love, and the pain and 
shock I went through was one of the most 
difficult. experiences of my life. What is more 
important now, however, is that nothing has 
changed between Dan and I since he came out. 

I finally understand everything about him 
and no longer need to wonder why we are so 
perfectly matched. and yet not going out to- 


COMING OUT... 


gether, There is nothing different about him or 
about us now, which brings me back to reflect 
upon my original mission — to “get to know 
more gay people so I could better understand 
their culture.” It makes me laugh when I think 
of my statement now, but | guess sometimes 
one is too close to a situation to see it clearly. 

| do not think I realised how true it is to say 
that gay people are your co-workers, your 
doctors, your friends, your children. Although 
| knew of my gay classmate, my gay professor 
and my gay colleague, I perceived my own little 
sheltered world as straight. | would never have 
thought the person | consider to be most 
similar to me, who | love the most in the world, 
to be gay. 

By knowing a gay individual, | do not neces- 
sarily understand gay culture. Furthermore, if 
I knew twenty gay people, I would not likely be 
able to classify them as a uniform group of 
people. This is the naiveté that I possessed 
before and that [laugh at now. 

I wanted to know what gay people were like 
and to discover how interesting | thought they 
must be. In reality, ] would find as much 
diversity, if not more, in this culture as in any 
other. 

Homophobia is a fear of homosexuals, a 
fear of someone who is too different to 
accept, When you open your eyes, the reality 
is that there is no fundamental difference at 
all. 


AND BEING ACCEPTED 


for other women. | realised — with surprise 
— that I wanted to get to know her, to ask her 
outon areal “date,” and to see if a relation- 
ship could develop. 

This thought terrified me. It signaled an 
awakening I knew could not be silenced or 
ignored. What would my boyfriend think? My 
family and friends? What about the marriage 
and kids that I’d always wanted? 

So much for having “no problem” with queer 
sexuality! What the fuck was I going to do? 


An ear to listen 


The logical answer was to seek out people who 
had the same feelings that! did, sol went to the 
LBGM (now LBGTM) office’ for the Peer 
Counseling I had seen advertised. 

There I was, welcomed by a non-judgmen- 
tal counselor who advised me that LBGM was 
a place where I wouldn’t be asked to label my 


sexuality unless I wanted to. 1 started going 


to the biand women’s discussion groups and 
finally found other people who felt the same 
angst and-attractions that 1 did, 


I was relieved and overjoyed atthe variety of 


people ‘in. the: queer. community, My naïve 
preconception of what it meant to be “queer” 
was shattered very quickly, and] realised that 


being queer was whatever J wanted it to be. 


[ started coming out to my friends, boy- 


friend and siblings, all of whom were amaz- 
ingly accepting. 1 — like many queers — was 


so afraid that people would desert me when 


they knew THE: TRUTH. Luckily it didn't 


happen, Letting people I: loved see this part 


of'me helped to further my own self-accept-: 
“ance: GY 


THE MSGILL DAILY SPECIAL ISSUE (177 NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


Subtle hint... 
The only people left were my parents — ack! 
I’ve always had a very intimate and open rela- 
tionship with my parents about everything 
except sex. | knew telling them was something 
had to do as the final stage of my coming out. 
| kept putting it off untilone day my mother 
found my copy of The Penguin Book of Lesbian 
Short Stories. That weekend, | asked my par- 
ents if I could talk to them about “something 
important.” They, my sister Maureen and |, 
gathered on their big bed — the location of all 
of our important family talks. 

After beating around the bush for a while, | 
finally said the words “I’m bisexual.” 

[was shocked at my physical reaction. Burst- 
ing into tears, | cried out, “I can’t believe I've 
finally told you.”:1 immediately felt myself 
being embraced by my mother and my sister, 
and my father held my hand. | silently thanked 
“God” (despite my agnosticism) and knew then 


“that “everything would be alright.” 


My identity 


This:is hardly the end of my story. My straight 
boyfriend andihave had an extremely difficult 
time trying to deal.with my bisexuality. 

I question myself all the time'and still buy 
into the idea that I have to be either gay or 
straight. ] often wish I could “go back” to being 
straight or else devote myself to being a “true” 


dyke. 2 


Now I’m carving out my own definition of 
what bisexual means for me. Although my life 
is definitely more complicated, itis much richer 
than before 1 came out. Jam living my life the 
only way | can-~ my way. 








8 Little ¢;. 


Imost one year and over 


a quarter of a million 
dollarsin expenses later, 
Little Sisters Bookstore in 
Vancouver is still waiting to 
hear the verdict in its case 
against Canada Customs, 

The precedent-setting 
court case in which Little Sis- 
ters challenged the right of 
Customs Lo seize so-called ‘ob- 
scene’ literature was heard in 
the BC Supreme Court from 
October to December 1994, 

Little Sisters, Which carries 
literature for Vancouver's gay, 
lesbian, bisexual and 
transgendercommunities, has 
had its shipments seized re- 
peatedly 
since 1985, {& 
The confis- 
cated arti- a 
cles some- |,& 
times in- à 
cluded pub- | 
lications al- 
lowed into 
mainstream 
bookstores, 

Little Sis- 
ters decided 
lo take ac- 
lion — last 
vear, Fed up 
with having 
to chailenge 
each seizure Se 
On a case by case basis, the 
store is questioning the legal- 
ity of Customs’ powers of de- 
lainment, 

The store argued that Cus- 
toms’ use of the term “ob- 
scenity” is unclear and 
critcised Customs for target- 
Ing gay and lesbian authors 
and bookstores while being 
more tolerant of heterosexual 
literature, 

According to Kim Mistysyn, 
from the Glad Day bookstore 
in Toronto, one of the big 
problems is that Customs of- 
licials receive little training 
in pornography and free 
speech issues. The only guid- 
ance they are given is a two 


hy - 


hour seminar on literature. 
During the triallast year, many 
Witnesses from Customs ad- 
mitted to this scanty training 
and still others said they found 
homosexuality “repulsive,” 

“Customs obviously does 
not have the experience or edu- 
cation to deal with books. They 
have repeatedly demonstrated 
their inability to keep things 
consistent, ‘” declared 
Mistysyn. 

The mistakes are revealing, 
Mistysyn pointed to a recent 
mishap surrounding the veg- 





etarian cookbook The Politics 


of Meat. Border guards glanced 
at the cover, assumed the book 


depicted gay sex, and seized 


it. 

“They would have realised 
if they had read a little of the 
book like they are supposed 
to,” noted Mistysyn. 

And then there is the dou- 
ble standard. Books depicting 
gay sex are routinely detained, 
Whereas literature involving 
heterosexual sex is allowed 
through without any difficulty. 
According to Fuller, 
Gay Sex was seized, while the 
heterosexual equivalent, The 


Joy of Sex, can be found on the 


shelves of virtually any Cana- 


INTERNATIONAL 


Queer cuts 





Potential victory in New 


South Wales 
The state of New South 


the state cabinet with a series — 


of reforms that will recognise 
Same-Sex couples and trans- 


Wales, Australia, might be the | gecxuals: 


next region to approve same=* 
sex unions. is 
Jeff Shaw, New South Wales 


attorney-general, will présents | 


Says Shaw, “Society ‘has. 


changed, and the community 
is ready to accept that rela- 


tionships as to be dealt tions at the United Nations 


NOVEMBER 13 NOVEMBRE, 1995 


The Joy of 


lers s Ol q 


dian bookstore. 

Customs officials also rou- 
tinely target independent 
bookstores while large chains 
such as Cole's are left alone. 
Mistysyn attributes this to the 
fact that border guards do not 
have time to look through the 
entire order of large shipments 
going to major chains. 

Independent bookstores 
cannot afford to import books 
in bulk and suspicious offi- 
cials are care- 
ful to search 
Bi the shipments 
headed for 
stores such as 
| Glad Day or Lit- 
| tle Sisters. Just 
| last year, Glad 
Day’s shipment 
of the famous 
American au- 
thor Samuel 
Delany’s book 
a) Madman was 
eee! scized, while 
Se | che Cole’s down 
| the street re- 
ceived its cop- 

Sa ies without any 
difficulty, 

Fuller commented that 
other marginalised groups 
have also been systematically 
targeted recently. Pointing to 
problems with prominent US 
feminist bell hooks’ last work, 
Fuller said she believes Cus- 
toms is beginning to “widen 
its scope” of censorship be- 
yond gay and lesbian books to 
include the literature of femi- 
nists and people of colour. 

But this phenomenon is not 
limited to Customs Canada. 


The attack against gay, les- 


bian, feminist literature has 
taken a new voice since 1992, 
when a Supreme Court of 
Canada ruling classified ‘de- 


with equitably, whether they 


are based on marriage or oth- 
crwise.” 

In support of transsexuals, 
Shaw hopes to extend the pro- 
tection of the state’s Anti-Dis- 
crimination Act, as well as in- 
troduce a proposal to allow 
transsexuals to change their 
gender on their birth certifi- 
cates. 


Argentina’sroleinWom- 
en's Conference criticised 


_in Buenos Aires 


Members of Lebianas a la 
Vista marched in protest of 
the Argentinean government's 
support of anti-lesbian posi- 


liant 


BOOKSTORES FACE 
ARBITRARY HARASS- 
MENT AT BORDER 


By Andrea Mason 


grading’ and ‘dehumanising’ 
sexual expression as criminal 
obscenity. That decision has 
been used continually by offi- 
cials and judges to declare that 
homo-erotic expression is de- 
grading as well. 

In a recent interview with 


the Advocate, Bruce Walsh of 


the anti-censorship coalition 
Censorstop commented that, 
“Every gay bookseller in this 
country has attempted to sell 
their bookstores, but nobody 
wants to buy them.” 

There is a lot of support for 
the Little Sister’s initiative, as 
Customs has a history of con- 
flict with gay and lesbian book- 
stores in Canada. According to 
Mistysyn, the fact that there 
are only three specifically gay 
and lesbian bookstores in 
Canada makes it easy for offi- 
cials to keep track of the ship- 
ments imported by these 
stores, 

Glad Day has had its share 
of hassles with the border 
guards, After numerous in- 
stances of prolonged shipment 
detention without notification, 
the store was forced to start 
importing through a broker, 
Although this is an extra ex- 


Fourth World Conference on. 


Women in Beijing. Demonstra- 
tors were extremely displeased 
by the exclusion of lesbian 
rights at the conference and 
marched with banners read- 
ing “Lesbian Rights are Hu- 
man Rights.” 

Youcan contact Lesbianasa 
la Vista at Piedras 1170 lero.B, 
(1070) Buenos Aires, Argen- 
tina and ales@wawani.apc.org. 


Denmark’s Same Sex 


marriage policy. 


In a display of protest, two 


leaders of Denmark's national 
queer organisation were mar- 
ried. The queer couple con- 
sists of a lesbian and gay HAT 





pense, it ensures that officials 
will be forced to at least give 
notice when they seize a ship- 
ment at the Canada/US bor- 
der. 

While Janine Fuller of Little 
Sisters said “There is less im- 
position of state will on the 
private domain” in Québec, 
the Montréal bookstore 
L'Androgyne has also been on 
Custom’s hit list in the past. 

Fuller admitted that book- 
stores carrying gay, lesbian, 
bisexual and transgendered 


literature are starting to buckle. 


under the pressure. “We end 
up censoring ourselves,” said 
Fuller. 

The resultis that some pub- 
lications, such as the lesbian 
erotic magazine Bad Attitude, 
have “effectively been banned 
in Canada,” said Fuller. 

But Little Sisters continues 
to be defiant, because, as Fuller 
stated, “A gay and lesbian 
bookstore is one of the few 
places where gays can see their 
ideas and history repre- 
sented.” 


The marriage was intended 
to protest provisions in Dan- 
ish law that withhold certain 
rights granted to opposite sex 
couples, such as adoption and 
access to artificial insemina- 
tion. 

Denmark was the first 
country in the world to allow 
same-sex unions in 1989, a 
decision soon followed by 
many Other European na- 
tions. 

In a related story, Eigil 
Axgil, part of the first couple 


. to be legally married in the 


world, died at the age of 71. 
He had been happily married 


for six years with his lover 


Axel Axgil, The couple’ had 


been soccer for Gly peus : 


“THE MCGILL DAILY Spcciail sue 





_ _— aE ee 2 ee oe eS 





Ed SEE ns — = 


CLASSIFIED ADS 


Ads may be placed through the Dail 

Business Office, Room B-07, 
University Centre, 9h00-14h00. 
Deadline is 14h00, two working days 
prior to publication.) McGill 
Students & Staff (with valid ID): 
$4.55 per day, 3 or more consecutive 
days, $4.00 per day. General 
Public: $5.70 per day, or $4.85 per 
aay for 3 of more consecutive days. 
Extra charges may apply and prices 
do not include applicable GST (7%) or 
PST (6.5%). Full payment should 
accompany your advertising order and 
may be made in cash or by pese 
cheque (for amounts over $20 oniy). 
For more information, please visit our 
office or call 398-6790. WE CANNOT 
TAKE CLASSIFIED ADS OVER THE 
PHONE. PLEASE CHECK YOUR 
AD CAREFULLY WHEN IT APPEARS 
IN THE PAPER, The wet? assumes no 
financial responsibility for errors, or 
damages due to errors. Ad will re- 
appear free of charge upon request if 
information is incorrect due to our 
error. The Daily reserves the right not 


to print any classified ad. 


Going Away for Christmas? 
How about sub tt me your apart- 
ment to host my family from Europe. | 
am a clean, responsible mature stu- 
dent. Phone 279-8724. 


O0 Ing or a better place 
to live? Sunny bedroom in a 73 in 
Outremont (Querbes & Bernard), Close 
to transportation, cheap ethnic food. 
Non-smoker preferred. $300/month. 


Everything included. Tel 279-0768. 
2-MOVERS/STORAGE 


Moving/Storage. Closed van or 
truck local & long distance. Ott-Tor- 
Van-NY-Fla-7 days, 24 hours, low 
rates. Steve 735-8148. 


3-HELP WANTED 











Models, actors, extras. 
Opportunities for all ages and sizes. 
Fashion, TV, print, film. 633-8605. 


Christmas gift wrappers— 
Creative individuals, locations— 
downtown Toronto, North York, 
Woodbine Centre, Mississauga. 


















= eee SE SS LS 








Managers to $8.25/hour+bonuses. 
Wrappers to $7.15/hour. Full/Part 
une December 1-24. 416-538- 





1-HOUSING 


Role-Model req'd to live in close 
proximity to young mothers experienc- 
ing independent living. Free rent. Role-Model req'd to live in close 
Lachine duplex. Info: Carol Norman proximity to young mothers experienc- 
482-2488. ing independent living. Free rent. 


1} to sublet, clean, sunny & quiet. Lachine duplex. Info: Carol Norman 
Near St-Laurent tOmin” walk to | 482-2488. 

McGill. Balcony, hardwd floors, 
security. $380/month 845-8637. 


CRUISE SHIPS 
HIRING Earn up to 
$2,000+ per month 


working for Cruise Ships or Land-Tour Companies. 
World Travel (Hawaii, Mexico, the Caribbean, etc.). 
Seasonal and Full-Time employment available. No exp. 
necessary. For info call: (© 

= 


gee 












Students Needed! 


Cruise Employment Services 
(206) 634-0468 ext. C40052 





TRAVEL ABROAD & WORK! 


+ Teach Conversational English in Asia * 
Make up to $25-$45 per hour teaching basic conversational English 
abroad. Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea. Positions also available 
in Thailand, China, and Indonesia. Many Employers provide room 
& board plus other benefits. No teaching background or Asian 
languages required. For more information, call one of our 
representatives at International Employment Group: 
PM INTERNATIONAL (206)632-1146 


we EMPLOYMENT 
f? e f2 6) Ue ext. J40052 





FREE milkshake or soup 


with purchase of an 


sandwich with this ad. 
$1.80 value) 





Les Cours oneal 


(Food Court metro level 


1455 Peel St. 


(between de Maisonneuve and 
Ste. Catherine) 


PEEL 





EXPIRES: NOVEMBER 2795 


Our Specialties are served with your choice of Salad or Fruits. 
Croque Monsieur: smoked ham, smoked gruyère on crusty 


White breads Grid annee $3.73 
Le Californien: smoked turkey on rye bread. $4.25 
L’Italien: Prosciutto, light Provolone cheese on pumpernickle 
Loreen ch seer eerie Re tee tste $4.25 
L'Original: Roast Beef, New Zealand Edam cheese on Kaiser 
bun? Grilled 2e Sea eae enr $4,25 
Le Moulin Vert: French Brie on baguette... $4.85 


[eS Ss ss Se Se ss 








me ee mes em = ee à Ce € CRE commen © CE 5 me 6 mt oe 


Personal trainer required in the 
Park Ave. & Prince Arthur area. 
Sessions 2 or 3 times per week in 
evenings & weekends. Knowledge of 
nutrition plus squash will be an asset. 
Please call on weekends or after 2100 
on weekdays. Tel. 843-3502. 


Do you like candles? Partylite fea- 
tures unique collection of candles & 
home decor accessories. Seeking 
consultants (party plan). No invest- 
ment. 727-4256. 


Quebec Franchi$e magazine 
looking for graduate able to translate 

eneral business text from French to 
: i Leth on contract basis. Call 287- 











5-WorpD PROCESSING/TYPING 


Success to all students. 
WordPerfect 5.1. Term papers, 
resumes, applications, transcription 
of micro-cassettes. Editing of gram- 
mar, 27 yrs. experience. $1.75/D.S.P, 
7 days/week. Campus / Peel / 


Sherbrooke. Paulette / Roxanne 288- 
9638/288-0016. 


McGill College/Sherbrooke 
quality word processing of term 
papers, theses, résumés, bilingual. 
Also diskette RTE EL at 600 
dpi. Ginette 848-0423. 


Word-processing term papers: 
theses, reports, etc. WordPerfect 
5.1. Laser printer. Fast, professional 
service. Good Rates. 10 Ve expe- 
rience. Close to McGill. Brigitte 282- 


Word Processing 
Fast professional typing 
apers, documents, resumes 
xecu-Centre 1200 McGill 
College 11th Floor 20% Discount for 
Students 393-1100 


Professional wordprocessing. 
$1.50/page. Same-day service, 
downtown, editing, laser. For all your 
SRI EAN ETATS academic 
papers, CV, graphic, etc. M-F 1:00am- 
6pm. Wendy 499-0140. 


6-SERVICES OFFERED 


Experienced editor/proofread- 
er/ writer/tutor. Help with your stu- 
dent papers, theses, manuscripts, 
résumés translation Spanish/French 
/English. Call Marian 765-9804 7 
Days/week 





Foreign students & visitors. 
DV-1 Greencard posent available. 
Tel: 818-772-7168 & 818-882-9681. 
rs Stagg st. Canoga Park 


Post Office 
Varieté David Cho 
Closest to McGill 2001 University. 
Mon-Fri 8:00am-6:00pm. We offer 
parcel service. Priority courier, 
xpress post, registered mail, money 
orders etc. Tel. 844-6455, 


Translation from English to French, 
and editing, on WP5.1, by prof., member 
of Ordre des Traducteurs agrés du 
Québec. 257-1253, 


Save Time and Money 
University application kits 
procurement service for any North 
American Graduate egree 
Tel. 486-4945 Fax. 486-2186. 


Pet Care: 


Looking for someone to feed 
and care for your pet over the holi- 
days? Call Jo-anne 524-1689, 


7-FOR SALE 
Attn Architecture 


gineering professiona 
“Norman Wade” drafting table com- 

lete with “Vemco” drafting machine 
’x3’ price negotiable 282-9557. 


9-WANTED To Buy 












Sound too good to be true. 
Make money while going to class. We 


pay for your lecture notes: Call 936-6466 
11-LOST & FOUND 


Se ee 
Tabby-cat found. To give away. 


Prya. 989-8516. 
13-LESSONS/COURSES 






Learn French with a qualified 
experienced teacher/ also tutoring 
children all levels. Atwater/de 
Maisonneuve 7 days/week. 932-9035. 


Authentic School of 


Esoteric Studies 
25-week evening course totally 
free-of-charge to study oneself/life 
and awaken consciousness based on 
direct experience. All are welcome. Info 
session 16 Nov & 18 Nov, 1015 
Atwater. U.C. Gnostic Movement: a 
non-profit, non-religious, humanitarian 
and int'l organization. (514)-384-1982: 


14-NOTICES 
I 
McGill Nightline open 9pm-3am a 
confidential and anonymous line. We 


offer listening, referrals and informa- 
tion. Call at 398-6246 398-MAIN. 


sage 





















Department of Physical Education 
Faculty of Education 
WINTER 1996 


434-392R.01: Nutrition & Wellness 


Wednesday & Friday - 9:00-10:30 - Room 408, Currie Gym Bldg. 

This course examines the role of carbohydrates, fats, proteins, 
vitamins, minerals and water in a balanced diet. Students will 
be introduced to the effects of nutrition on exercise, sport 
performance and wellness. The concept of wellness from an 
active living and stress reduction perspective will also be 
discussed, 


434-502Y.61: Selected Iisues: Sport medicine 


Wednesdays - 17:00-20:00 - Room 152, Currie Gym Bldg, 

Are you interested in understanding the healing process of 
common sport injuries? À new course is being offered that 
focuses on these issues. Aimed at physical educators, coaches, 
trainers, and taught by sport medicine physicians, the course 
will review recent scientific developments in the rapidly growing 
field of sports medicine. 


English Language Courses 


95 


December 


Conversation (cight levels) 
TOEFL Preparation 
Writing for the CELDT 


Registration Fee (non-refundable) 
Late Registration Fee (commencing November 28) .. 


Monday to lriday 
10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. (40 hours) 


December 4 to December 15 


Days: 
Time: 
Dates: 
Registration in person before November 23 
848-3608 

1822 de Maisonneuve Blvd. W. 

Montreal, Quebec H3H 148 


Call Now: 


Centre for 
Continuing 
Education 


“| Concordia 


“wy UNIVERSITY 


REAL EDUCATION FOR THE REAL WORLD 


Sexual Assault 
Centre of McGill 


Have you been 
sexually harassed 
or assaulted here? 


ACCOMPANIMENT AND ADVOCACY 
PROGRAMME: 


Trained volunteers from the Sexual Assault Centre of 
McGill Students Society, an organization made up of students 
who are committed to working together to stop sexual 
harassment and assault, will provide information, support 
and accompaniment services to members of the McGill 
community who are considering taking action against their 
aggressors through the university grievance procedures. 


Students’ Society 


Sexual harassment and assault are prohibited under the 
McGill University Code of Student Conduct 
Find out what you can do about it af McGill. 


CALL US 
398-2700 Mon-Fri, 9:30-5:30 
398-8500, Seven days a week, 6:00 pm-12:00 am 
William Shatner University Centre, Room 430 








YOUR DOWNTOWN 
A CCESS Info-Tecn EPSON SERL CE 
AE 


IN STORE STUDENT FINANCING 
Tough on Fe 
Road, Easy on St en: 
the Budget. 





FNEEOQ Association des Etudiant-e-s 


Diplômé-e-s Employé-e-s de McGill 


SCTIL 


Association of Graduate Students 
Employed at McGill 





CSN 
Union Tour 


è 
À ction N ote Coming soon to your department. 
In November, members of the coordinating 
6 b () C 6 () LO [/ R committee and your local representative 
- Fast 486D.X2-66MHz Processor will be setting up a meeting in your building. 


; | The meeting will include background on 
- Large 10.3" Passive Colour Display AGSEM, what is going on in bargaining 


with Built-In Local Bus Video with McGill, the vacation pay issue and 
- SMB Ram , 340MB HDD, 3.5" FD any other questions you want to raise. 


- Type III PCMCIA Slot Coffee and donuts will be provided. 
- Built-In Trackball We'll see you there. 
$79 permonth 


LIMITED QUANTITY. CASH PRICE ONLY 


r Room 12, Suite 2401, 2020 University Street, Montréal, Québec, H3A 2A5 
444 Rene-Levesque West. 1120 DeMaisonneuve West y ; ; ; 
Conver Blears Corner Stanley Tel: (514) 398-2582. Fax: (514) 398-2623. email: agsem@facl.lan.mcglll.ca 


UL 471O 


mown 








p d'Arts Tel.: (514) 288 - 6000 Tel: (514)288-6000 PEL 





imprimerie — reprographie 


= = COPIE EXPRESS 


(corner of University & Ne 680 SH ERBROO KE WEST 











| The all new digital printshop of the 90’s. 


DON’T MISS THIS GREAT 


ce py OPPORTUNITY 
. fe A it < cy Visit us and take advantage of our special 


a “an LD) discount for students and faculty. 
(D ji A 
ie ve ae 





20% 


UNTIL NOV. 30) NOV. UNTIL NOV. 30) 











"a 


Ansar 
ws Any 





7 
mets'C 
Award’ Wo, 









Mon: Fri: 
. some 10: 00m 





680 SHERBROOKE WEST 
corn ner of University & McGill) . 


~ 20 -